Why the Ladybug Clock Puzzle Has Probability 1/11

A random-walk argument turns a surprising simulation into a symmetry proof.

채널
3Blue1Brown
게시일
2026년 2월 16일
영상
2:33
읽기
1분
슬라이드
3
원문
영어
YouTube에서 열기
스크롤하면 영상이 오른쪽 아래로 작아져 계속 재생됩니다. 자막은 읽기 언어를 따릅니다.
읽기 언어2개 언어로 읽을 수 있음
이 글은 아직 한국어 번역이 없어 영어 원문으로 표시합니다.
요약

30초 요약

3Blue1Brown solves the ladybug clock puzzle by waiting for a first visit to a neighbor of the target. The resulting random-walk question is identical for all eleven possible last numbers, giving each probability 1/11.

  1. 1Equal-looking outcomesSimulations suggest the eleven possible last numbers are equally likely.
  2. 2Wait for a neighborThe ladybug eventually reaches a neighbor of the target with probability one.
  3. 3Reduce to a random walkFrom there the relevant walk must reach +10 before −1.
  4. 4Every number has probability 1/11The same argument applies to every number other than the starting point.

핵심 정리

  1. Simulations suggest the eleven possible last numbers are equally likely.
  2. The ladybug eventually reaches a neighbor of the target with probability one.
  3. From there the relevant walk must reach +10 before −1.
  4. The same argument applies to every number other than the starting point.
전문

챕터별로 다듬은 전문 읽기

원본 자막만 보기
01

The clock puzzle

A ladybug’s random walk colors numbers on a clock.

A ladybug starts at 12 on a clock and takes random steps clockwise or counterclockwise, each with equal probability. Every number she touches turns red. What is the probability that 6 is the last number to be colored?

Simulation of last numbers
슬라이드 1 / 3Simulation of last numbersThe chart shows the approximate frequencies after hundreds of trials.

When I simulate the walk many times and record the final number, all numbers from 1 through 11 appear about equally likely. That is surprising: one might initially expect 6, opposite the start, to be less likely than 1 or 11.

02

Wait for a neighbor

Reframe the question at the first visit to either neighbor of the target.

The key is to wait until the ladybug first reaches either neighbor of 6, namely 5 or 7. This eventually happens with probability one, so waiting for that moment does not change the probability of the final outcome.

Approaching a neighbor of 6
슬라이드 2 / 3Approaching a neighbor of 6From 7, reaching 5 without touching 6 makes 6 the last number.

Suppose she reaches 7 first. For 6 to be last, she must reach the still-untouched 5 by going around the other way before ever touching 6. That is a net ten steps clockwise before one step counterclockwise. Once she reaches 5 this way, every other number has been colored.

03

The same probability for all

The same random-walk problem applies to each possible last number.

Straighten the circle into a random walk: each step is +1 or −1 with equal probability, and the question is whether the walk reaches +10 before −1. We do not need to calculate this directly to finish the argument.

Nothing about the argument is special to 6. For 3, wait until the ladybug first reaches 2 or 4, then the same ten-steps-versus-one-step question applies. The probability is identical for every possible final number from 1 to 11, so each must have probability 1/11.

The same argument for 3
슬라이드 3 / 3The same argument for 3The diagram shows the ten-step route and the one-step forbidden direction.

같은 채널의 다른 글

슬라이드 20장40:44EN
3Blue1Brown· 2026년 10월 16일Grant Sanderson: There's never been a better time to go into mathGrant Sanderson, Constantin Kogler · 3Blue1BrownStudents fear AI has solved mathematics. Grant Sanderson argues the opposite: even if machines prove theorems better than we do, the institution of math stays valuable—and this is a rare moment when newcomers can reshape it.MathematicsAI for scienceHuman-AI Collaboration+2
슬라이드 29장51:55EN
3Blue1Brown· 2026년 9월 18일The last IMO problem AI could not solveGrant Sanderson · 3Blue1BrownGrant Sanderson walks through IMO 2025 Problem 6 — a tiling puzzle that frontier models missed — and the visual patience it takes to prove a construction is optimal.MathematicsAI researchReasoning & test-time compute+2
0:55EN
3Blue1Brown· 2026년 7월 24일The 64 Sugar Cubes Puzzle: Six Equal DistancesA 4×4×4 block has three colors; prove that six same-colored pairs share a distance.MathematicsEducation
슬라이드2:25EN
3Blue1Brown· 2026년 6월 12일How Shannon Measured the Entropy of EnglishA guessing game helped Claude Shannon estimate how much information English text contains, and why prediction is central to compression.MathematicsAI History
슬라이드1:02EN
3Blue1Brown· 2026년 6월 10일A Robot Walk and the Puzzle of Optimal Binary EncodingHow few bits does it take to send directions that occur with unequal frequencies?MathematicsScience Communication
슬라이드 4장32:19EN
3Blue1Brown· 2026년 6월 7일Reinventing Entropy: Why Prediction Helps Compress LanguageA robot’s movement code leads from prefix-free encoding to Shannon information and the entropy of language.MathematicsScience Communication