Early Nano Banana Image Editing Examples and a Hands-On Test

Matthew Berman examines selective edits, photo restoration and image composition, then tries several prompts in LM Arena.

MBMatthew Bermanホスト · Forward Future
チャンネル
Matthew Berman
公開日
2025年8月21日
動画
13:13
読了時間
3 分
スライド
5
原文
英語
YouTube で開く
スクロールすると動画は右下に小さくなって再生を続けます。字幕は閲覧言語に合わせて切り替わります。
閲覧言語2 言語で読めます
この記事はまだ日本語に翻訳されていないため、英語の原文を表示しています。
要約

30 秒でわかる

In this August 21, 2025 video, Matthew Berman reviews early examples of the image model known as Nano Banana and tests it in LM Arena. He praises its ability to preserve parts of an image while changing others, while noting imperfect text, product shapes and likenesses. The video includes a Chatbase sponsorship.

  1. 1Selective editsA shopping-cart example adds a dog-food bag while retaining much of the surrounding scene.
  2. 2Restoration and colorizationBerman shows repaired photographs; generated colors and missing details may be inferred rather than historically accurate.
  3. 3Combining referencesA composite puts people, a dog and a car together from separate images.
  4. 4Product placement comparisonA selected example contrasts two models on inserting a specific bottle into an image.
  5. 5A hands-on comparisonBerman edits his own portrait and observes that preferences differ depending on the request.

ポイント

  1. Selective editing can preserve much of a scene while adding or replacing an object, but details may still change.
  2. Restored photographs and imagined viewpoints can contain plausible invented colors or details.
  3. Image composition and product placement examples show potential as well as errors in text, hands and shapes.
  4. The comparisons are small, selected demonstrations rather than a rigorous ranking of models.
  5. The LM Arena access method and attribution discussion reflect what was known when the video was recorded.
トピックGenerative media
全文

チャプターごとに整えた全文を読む

文字起こしのみ
01

Early image-editing examples

Berman reviews additions, composites and a mesh-like overlay. He then shows photo restoration and colorization.

In August 2025, a model known as Nano Banana appeared in LM Arena’s image battles. I look at examples shared by others and try a few edits myself, focusing on how well it changes one part of an image while preserving the rest.

One example asks the model to add a third bag of dog food to a shopping cart. The result keeps much of the scene and packaging consistent, although I notice some imperfections in the dog illustration.

Adding a bag to a shopping cart
スライド 1 / 5Adding a bag to a shopping cartA selective edit inserts a third bag while preserving much of the original scene.

A generated selfie combines a young Michael Jackson and Billie Eilish. I find the image convincing, which also illustrates that a realistic composite is not evidence that the depicted event occurred.

Another example overlays a 3D-looking mesh on a photograph of Tom Holland. The mesh appears to follow the clothing and pose, but the picture alone does not prove that a correct underlying 3D model was recovered.

Several examples repair and colorize damaged or faded photographs. The results can be visually appealing, but inferred colors and reconstructed details should not be assumed to record the original scene accurately.

02

The model’s appearance and sponsor

He describes finding Nano Banana in LM Arena and speculates about its origin. The video includes a Chatbase sponsorship.

At the time, people encountered Nano Banana through random matchups in LM Arena. I interpret a banana emoji posted by Google’s Logan Kilpatrick as a clue that Google may be behind it; this was an inference at the time of the video.

03

Composition and limitations

Examples cover reference styles, generated viewpoints, combining subjects and editing books. Some outputs have incorrect details.

After a sponsored segment for Chatbase, I show a four-panel sports montage that follows a reference style. Other examples colorize an image, imagine the reverse view of a scene and create an advertisement; unseen parts of a scene are generated guesses.

Combining multiple image references
スライド 2 / 5Combining multiple image referencesThe model composes a man, a woman, a dog and a car into a single generated scene.

One composite combines separate images of a man, a woman, a dog and a car. Details such as the chef’s clothing carry through, illustrating multi-image composition, although not every property of the source car is easy to verify.

An example puts Tim Cook with a rumored phone, but I find the handset awkwardly shaped and oversized. Another replaces Batman with Superman while preserving the cat; the change is not perfect, but the unchanged element remains consistent.

A hat is added to a portrait, and another instruction turns a stack of books upright between bookends. The book example exposes a limitation: some names and lettering become unclear or altered after the edit.

04

Comparisons and hands-on tests

Berman compares selected outputs and describes how he accessed battle mode. His own edits show both strengths and imperfect likenesses.

A comparison with GPT Image 1 gives two different visual styles for the same prompt. I prefer the more realistic-looking result in this example, but one selected output is not a general benchmark.

A product-placement example compares FLUX.1 Kontext with Nano Banana on inserting a particular beer bottle into a character’s hand. In the displayed outputs, Nano Banana retains the bottle more closely, while the FLUX example produces a glass and a problematic hand.

Product placement comparison
スライド 3 / 5Product placement comparisonThe displayed outputs show different approaches to inserting a specific bottle into a character’s hand.

Other examples combine public figures in a generated beach scene and place a chair beside a lamp. In the latter, I like the light and patterned shadows; these are selected demonstrations rather than proof of consistent performance on every prompt.

At the time of recording, the way to try it was to choose image generation and battle mode in LM Arena, then wait for the service to select Nano Banana randomly. Availability and access methods described here reflect August 2025.

Editing a portrait background
スライド 4 / 5Editing a portrait backgroundBerman compares two image models on placing his portrait in space.

For my own test, I ask to remove the background from a portrait and place me in space. Compared with the Gemini 2.0 Flash image shown beside it, I prefer the Nano Banana result because it preserves my face more closely.

I then add a space helmet and ask for slightly tinted glass, comparing Nano Banana with Qwen Image Edit. For the tint, I actually prefer the Qwen example, showing that the result depends on the particular edit.

Tinting a helmet visor
スライド 5 / 5Tinting a helmet visorFor this edit, Berman prefers the Qwen Image Edit example over Nano Banana.

Finally I ask for a giant banana chasing me. The result is funny but does not look much like me, despite carrying some features forward. These early examples make me eager to test the model further.

同じチャンネルの記事

スライド 6 枚25:50EN
MBMatthew Berman· 2026年10月24日Kimi K3.1 Pro Tested: Strong 3D Demos, Uneven Results and Competitive PricingMatthew Berman · Forward FutureMatthew Berman tests the open-weight model on coding, 3D rendering and visual explanations, then compares benchmark results and prices.Open-weight modelsBenchmarksAI cost & performance+1
スライド 2 枚32:20EN
MBMatthew Berman· 2026年10月23日Who Is Local AI For? The Costs, Trade-offs and a Hybrid FutureMatthew Berman · Forward FutureMatthew Berman weighs data control and independence against hardware cost, setup complexity and inference speed.Local inferenceOpen-weight modelsAI cost & performance+1
スライド0:22EN
MBMatthew Berman· 2026年10月21日A Robot Bodyguard Video Shows Dramatic Rescue ScenariosMatthew Berman · Forward FutureMatthew Berman reacts to a short robot demonstration depicting fighting and vehicle-rescue scenarios.Robotics評価(Evals)
45:08EN
MBMatthew Berman· 2026年10月21日Sam Altman on AI Discovery, Consciousness, Compute and a Human-Centered FutureMatthew Berman, Sam Altman · Forward FutureIn a conversation with Matthew Berman, Altman discusses scientific progress, personal assistants, recursive self-improvement and the importance of human agency.AI for sciencePersonal agentsConsciousness+2
0:32EN
MBMatthew Berman· 2026年10月21日Sam Altman on the Continuing Demand for Software WorkSam Altman, Matthew Berman · OpenAIIn a short interview excerpt, Altman says demand for software may be larger than expected even as AI changes how it is made.Future of WorkSoftware engineeringコーディングエージェント
スライド 5 枚12:14EN
MBMatthew Berman· 2026年10月14日Gemini 4 Argon Tested: 3D Demos, a Spreadsheet Prototype and Benchmark ResultsMatthew Berman · Forward FutureMatthew Berman tests Google’s model on games and visual projects, then compares reported coding and agent benchmarks.GeminiBenchmarksコーディングエージェント+1