In 30 seconds
In 2019 Nio, Xpeng and Li Auto were all short of cash, with Nio under particularly urgent pressure. By 2020, funding and the electric-vehicle market had improved rapidly. Wang Pan, who has followed the industry for years, says the companies first had to secure money and show that customers wanted their cars. He compares Li Auto’s range-extender approach, Nio’s battery swapping and brand building, and Xpeng’s technology focus: each serves different needs and demands different resources and execution.
- 1Range extenders made Li Auto fundraising harderWang says some early investors favored fully electric vehicles and were reluctant to back Li Auto’s range-extender approach.
- 2Swapping and range extenders addressed range anxietyThe companies had different resources and chose different ways to solve users’ charging concerns.
- 3Cash pressure differedWang recalls that all three needed money in 2019, but Nio faced particularly urgent pressure.
- 4Funding conditions changed in 2020Nio secured investment from Hefei as expectations for electric vehicles and capital markets also changed.
- 5Competition shifted toward winning customersWang believes that as EVs gained acceptance, investors focused more on which companies could prevail.
Takeaways
- All three companies faced funding pressure, but Nio’s cash situation was especially urgent in 2019.
- Before the market turned in 2020, continued deliveries and investment helped the companies survive.
- Li Auto’s range extender and Nio’s battery swapping used different ways to address range anxiety.
- Wang believes the founders’ preferences for branding, practical features and technology shaped their product choices.
- Long car development and replacement cycles can leave opportunities for later entrants.
Read the edited text by chapter
Why revisit the new automakers?
Wang explains why he followed electric vehicles and recalls the founders’ early experiences.
Zhang Xiaojun asks Wang Pan why he wrote a long retrospective on new automakers in 2020. He says late 2019 and the first half of 2020 brought a dramatic turn: companies had been watching their cash closely, then funding and share prices suddenly improved.
Wang began covering the industry in 2015. He recalls calling Li Bin, who was in a meeting and promised to call back later. Li did call that evening, and they discussed the EP9 then under development.
He followed cars because the industry was enormous and Tesla’s development suggested a new opportunity might emerge in China.
Wang recalls Li Bin and Qin Lihong meeting at an auto industry event in 2014 and repeatedly discussing building cars afterward. Li Xiang also joined the talks and ultimately participated in Nio as an investor and cofounder.
Zhang notes that Li Bin and Li Xiang had previously run car-focused media businesses. Wang says Bitauto and Autohome were in the same category but differed in style and audience size.
After leaving Autohome, Li Xiang reviewed the successes and failures of his previous ventures with investor Huang Mingming. Wang says he mentioned his plan to build cars only at the end of one long conversation; former colleagues and investors later joined the project.
Xpeng’s early team first received investment from He Xiaopeng and others. Wang says investor Jixun Foo kept urging He to leave Alibaba and join the car company himself.
He Xiaopeng’s earlier ventures had already made him wealthy, and he hesitated over taking on the risk of a new project. Wang recalls Foo calling to encourage him when a child had just been born into his family; He ultimately decided to join.
Zhang asks why investors thought Xpeng needed He Xiaopeng. Wang says the auto industry’s long, complex supply chain requires someone who can lead the team; investors believed He’s experience running UC gave him that ability.
On why the company was named Xpeng before He formally joined, Wang cites different accounts: the official explanation was that other names failed registration, while others thought the team hoped to draw him in. He does not treat either account as certain.
Asked which of the three founders had more money, Wang says he does not know. He adds that after Li Xiang began building cars, he focused more attention on his new venture and reduced his involvement in other investments.
Hiring and funding
The three companies sought talent and capital, while investors differed in their views of technology paths.
The first problems for new automakers were hiring and funding. Wang says Nio attracted managers from established automakers and technology companies early on, while competing with other startups for talent.
He recalls that Shen Feng did not immediately join Nio. After observing the ES8 launch and the team’s progress, and taking more time to understand the company, Shen left his previous employer to join.
Wang knows more about Li Auto’s fundraising: after an early small-car project was abandoned, the company moved to range-extended vehicles. Some investors preferred fully electric cars, making fundraising difficult.
He estimates that this difficult period was around 2017 and says investors sometimes follow their peers’ choices. The range-extender approach was harder to back than the then-popular fully electric route.
By comparison, Wang recalls Nio’s early fundraising going relatively smoothly: Li Bin was prepared to invest his own money and spoke with investors including Lei Jun and Pony Ma, gradually gathering early backers.
Xpeng also approached several large companies. Wang says some investment offers came with strategic conditions, while He Xiaopeng wanted to keep control over core capabilities such as intelligent driving, so not every negotiation led to a deal.
Wang recalls that when He decided to leave Alibaba to build cars, he discussed the new venture while saying goodbye to management; Alibaba’s investment team subsequently began looking at Xpeng.
Li Auto initially relied more on familiar founders and venture investors. During a difficult fundraising period, Wang says, an investor suggested that Li Xiang seek support from wealthy friends; after a long conversation with Wang Xing, Li secured an investment.
First cars and different choices
Wang compares range extenders, battery swapping and the companies’ approaches to launching products.
Asked about the first cars each company produced, Wang first revisits Li Auto’s abandoned small-car project. He thinks the company understood a market need, but policy and funding uncertainty prevented the project from continuing.
Li Auto also discussed a partnership with Didi. Wang says it was never carried out and he no longer remembers all the disclosed details; Li Auto later formed an investment relationship with Meituan.
He explains Li Auto’s range-extender choice: at the time many customers were accustomed to gasoline cars and hesitant to switch fully to battery power. A range-extended car uses an onboard engine to generate electricity, offering another response to range anxiety.
Nio first established its brand with high-performance vehicles, then launched the ES8. Wang recalls a large launch event; a specific cost circulated publicly, but the company did not disclose an exact figure.
Xpeng’s first mass-produced car, the G3, was largely defined before He Xiaopeng joined. Wang believes the P7 was the first model whose product definition He deeply influenced.
The Li Auto ONE launch was much more modest. Wang recalls an event at the Changzhou factory, with guests arranging much of their own travel and accommodation; the company wanted to reserve more resources for the car.
Investor Huang Mingming initially worried about the simplicity of Li Auto’s exhibition stand. After speaking with engineers and visitors who had studied the product, he saw potential customers’ interest in the car itself.
An updated Xpeng G3 offered better specifications at a lower price. Some customers who had just bought the older version protested, and the company later apologized.
How a latecomer competed
He discusses Li Auto ONE, Xpeng products and the teams’ execution.
Wang says the market initially compared Nio and Xpeng with WM Motor more often. Li Auto delivered later, and outside attention and expectations were lower at the time.
He compares two people he knows: one experienced professional joined Nio, while another employee who joined Li Auto greatly valued the opportunity. He thinks differences in team experience can affect commitment and execution.
On strategy, he says Nio’s battery swapping and Li Auto’s range extender addressed range concerns in different ways. The companies’ different finances and resources also influenced their choices.
Wang says Li Xiang once told him Li Auto had only one chance to play its hand, so the Li Auto ONE had to succeed. Before delivery the team was especially sensitive to product problems and concentrated resources on the car.
Xpeng then released the P7, positioned against Tesla’s Model 3. Wang considers the P7 and later G6 successful, while the P5’s product definition did not meet some customers’ expectations.
He liked the G9’s driving experience but thinks early pricing and internal management affected its launch. Li Auto concentrated resources on a few models; Nio moved from higher to lower price points, with differing results across products.
The 2019 cash crunch
All three needed capital, while Nio also dealt with car fires and recalls.
In 2019, Wang says, all three faced a funding shortage, but Nio’s cash pressure was especially urgent. It kept operating with financing and investor support while also dealing with car fires and a recall.
He says Nio’s service network, battery-swap stations and research required substantial investment. Li Auto was also struggling to find funding, repeatedly explaining the business to potential investors.
Wang recalls Nio addressing a battery-pack issue and recalling some vehicles after fires; some owners also voluntarily promoted the brand. Xpeng received new funding during its difficult period.
Crossing the survival line
Local investment, sales and changing market conditions helped the companies reach a new funding phase.
The year 2020 was a turning point: Nio received investment from Hefei, attitudes toward electric vehicles changed, and shares of Tesla and new automakers rose, improving access to capital.
Wang thinks Tesla’s Chinese production and rising deliveries helped more people believe the EV market could grow. Changing capital-market conditions also helped these companies obtain funding.
Zhang summarizes that the companies had to survive until conditions improved. Wang agrees, adding that Nio’s continuing ES6 sales helped local investors see an opportunity.
Founders and company strategies
Wang compares branding, practical features and technology, and considers opportunities for later entrants.
Wang believes founders’ preferences shaped their companies’ products: Nio emphasized brand and design, Li Auto practical features customers could directly experience, and Xpeng technology and intelligent driving.
He compares Xpeng’s approach to Tesla’s: the P7 and G6 targeted comparable models and emphasized intelligent driving. Xpeng sought to move upmarket with higher-priced cars, but the G9 initially performed poorly.
Asked about other new automakers from the same period, Wang says many did not endure. He recalls early reporting and investigations into some projects, and investors’ judgments about different teams’ backgrounds.
Cars and phones have different cycles, Wang says: consumers generally replace cars less often, and car supply chains are more complex, so companies entering later may still have an opportunity.
Compared with 2019, he sees the major change as greater understanding of EVs. The question no longer centers solely on proving a market exists; competition has shifted toward whether individual companies can win customers.
He expects economies of scale to make the car market more concentrated, though perhaps less so than phones. Zhang notes that industry participants differ on the eventual market structure.
For the challenges at the time, Wang says Li Auto faced a new model and competitive pressure, Nio needed better execution and sales, and Xpeng needed to keep implementing its intelligent-driving strategy.
On Xiaomi’s impending entry into cars, Wang sees brand recognition and distribution as strengths, but says it still needs to catch up in intelligent driving and vehicle technology. Its coming models will determine how those strengths are put to use.
More from this channel
6:27:27ZH → English
1:59:52ZH → English
1:59:52EN
2:51:18EN
2:51:18ZH → English
2:34:18EN