Musk at CPAC: DOGE cuts, political change and a disputed fraud estimate

Musk and Rob Schmitt discuss government spending and immigration; Musk’s fraud estimate requires the scope of GAO’s data.

EMElon MuskゲストJMJavier Milei登壇者
チャンネル
Right Side Broadcasting Network
公開日
2025年2月20日
動画
35:50
読了時間
5 分
原文
英語
YouTube で開く
スクロールすると動画は右下に小さくなって再生を続けます。字幕は閲覧言語に合わせて切り替わります。
閲覧言語2 言語で読めます
この記事はまだ日本語に翻訳されていないため、英語の原文を表示しています。
要約

30 秒でわかる

At CPAC in February 2025, Elon Musk told Newsmax host Rob Schmitt why he had moved from political neutrality toward supporting Trump, and defended DOGE’s effort to cut federal spending. He discussed a possible taxpayer dividend and questioned Social Security records, while making unsubstantiated claims about immigration and political motives. His reference to government fraud needs context: GAO’s estimate covered $233 billion to $521 billion annually across the federal government, not a verified amount of recoverable savings. Musk also discussed NASA astronauts, the war in Ukraine and his own motivations.

  1. 1Musk explains his move into partisan politicsHe says he had leaned Democratic but became concerned about speech and personal freedoms. Schmitt supports his account.
  2. 2Musk says Trump supported exploring a DOGE dividendThe discussion treats checks as a possible future use of savings, not a payment already approved.
  3. 3Old Social Security records lead to a broader fraud discussionMusk describes implausible ages; Schmitt asks whether benefits were actually paid. Records without death dates do not establish payments.
  4. 4GAO’s fraud estimate covers the whole federal governmentMusk cites an upper estimate, but GAO’s range is $233 billion to $521 billion annually across government for fiscal years 2018–2022.
  5. 5Musk alleges politics affected astronauts’ returnNASA says it chose an uncrewed Starliner return in August 2024 and reassigned the astronauts to SpaceX Crew-9 for safety reasons.
  6. 6Musk traces his sense of purpose to American storiesHe says comics, games and television shaped his ideas about trying to do useful things.

ポイント

  1. Musk presented DOGE spending cuts and a potential taxpayer dividend as plans and expectations in February 2025.
  2. GAO’s fraud estimate was a government-wide range based on 2018–2022 data, not proof that a specific benefit program lost the upper estimate.
  3. A Social Security record lacking a death date does not by itself show that benefits are being paid to a deceased person.
  4. Musk alleged political motives behind immigration and astronaut return decisions; those motives were not established in the interview.
  5. Musk says American popular culture influenced his early sense of doing useful work.
トピック政治Economics
全文

チャプターごとに整えた全文を読む

文字起こしのみ
01

A chainsaw for bureaucracy

Schmitt introduces Musk, and Milei presents him with a symbolic chainsaw before the interview.

Newsmax host Rob Schmitt welcomes the CPAC audience and introduces Elon Musk. Argentine President Javier Milei joins them briefly and gives Musk a chainsaw as a symbol of cutting bureaucracy.

02

Musk explains his political shift

Schmitt asks how Musk moved from a relatively neutral stance to supporting Trump. Musk cites freedom of speech and personal liberty.

Elon Musk and Newsmax host Rob Schmitt begin by joking about memes and DOGE’s transformation from an internet reference into a government-efficiency initiative. Musk thanks the CPAC audience for its support.

They say politics should allow humor and free expression. Schmitt argues that the election changed the country’s political atmosphere, while Musk says he had felt the United States was approaching a point of no return.

Asked how he moved from business and relative political neutrality to supporting Trump, Musk says he had leaned Democratic but became concerned about restrictions on speech and personal freedoms. He argues that freedom and opportunity should be protected.

Schmitt asks whether negative media coverage and threats bother him. Musk says threats against his life are concerning, although the two continue to joke about the criticism.

03

DOGE savings and a possible dividend

The two discuss government spending and a proposed check funded by savings. Musk presents it as an initiative he says the president supported.

Schmitt praises DOGE’s spending reviews and questions how opponents can argue against reducing waste. Musk claims government funding has supported organizations and media that oppose his political views; he does not document the full allegation in this exchange.

They discuss Musk’s purchase of Twitter, now X. Musk says freedom of expression was a major motivation, while Schmitt argues that protecting speech justified a high price.

Musk argues that some media coverage reflects government influence. Schmitt agrees and asks about the proposed “DOGE dividend,” a possible check to taxpayers funded by savings.

Musk says he discussed the dividend with Trump and believes the president supports it. They mention a possible $5,000 payment, but no completed savings allocation or approved payment is established in the conversation.

Musk says the scale of federal spending surprised him and argues that careful review can identify large savings quickly. Schmitt says even smaller amounts matter to taxpayers.

04

Safety, Fort Knox and reviewing federal spending

Musk discusses threats and says he would like a public look at Fort Knox. He describes his approach to finding waste.

Schmitt asks about Musk’s safety after threats and political violence. Musk says he is open to better security and does not want to be harmed, while saying the work should continue.

They discuss Fort Knox. Musk says the gold belongs to the public and suggests a public or livestreamed inspection; he says he has not established that anything is missing and wants to see it.

Asked about the Federal Reserve and spending, Musk says he believes waste is widespread. He says the team is sharing findings publicly and that competence and attention can improve operations.

05

Social Security records and fraud estimates

Musk raises records with implausible ages. GAO’s federal fraud estimate has a broader scope than individual programs or demonstrated savings.

Musk describes Social Security database records with implausible ages. Schmitt asks whether checks are actually being paid on those records. The [Social Security Administration later explained](https://www.ssa.gov/blog/en/posts/2025-03-05-b.html) that records lacking a death date do not by themselves prove that the people listed are receiving benefits.

Musk refers to a fraud estimate and the two discuss entitlement programs. [GAO estimated](https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-24-105833) annual direct federal fraud losses of $233 billion to $521 billion across government based on fiscal 2018–2022 data. That is a range for government-wide losses, not an audit finding that the upper amount was lost in Social Security or that it could all be recovered.

Musk and Schmitt discuss fraud during the COVID-19 response and the possibility of money going abroad. Musk offers an estimate and argues that federal programs need stronger controls.

06

Immigration allegations and astronaut return

Musk alleges political motives behind immigration policy and the timing of astronauts’ return. NASA has described its separate safety-based decision for Crew-9.

Schmitt asks about immigration and reducing federal support for people without legal status. Musk alleges that the Biden administration used funding to encourage unauthorized immigration and links the policy to electoral incentives.

Musk and Schmitt speculate that immigration was intended to change future voting patterns. This is their allegation about political intent. [USAGov](https://www.usa.gov/who-can-vote) says noncitizens cannot vote in federal elections, and the interview does not establish the alleged scheme.

Schmitt asks whether the Biden administration delayed the return of astronauts to avoid benefiting Musk. Musk agrees with that interpretation and cites friction between SpaceX and the government. The conversation does not establish that alleged motive.

Musk points to the length of the astronauts’ stay on the International Space Station. [NASA said](https://www.nasa.gov/missions/station/commercial-crew/starliner-faq/) in August 2024 that, because of safety considerations, Boeing’s Starliner would return uncrewed and the astronauts would return as part of SpaceX Crew-9.

07

Benefits, Ukraine and Musk’s motivations

Musk says DOGE’s intent is to preserve benefits, argues for ending the war and describes the cultural influences that shaped him.

Schmitt raises concerns that DOGE could harm Social Security or Medicare. Musk says the team’s aim is to preserve those programs by addressing fraud and the deficit. He argues that rising debt interest could otherwise crowd out spending.

The conversation turns to Russia’s war in Ukraine. Musk and Schmitt argue for negotiations and emphasize the human cost to people fighting on both sides. Musk alleges corruption is prolonging the conflict; that is his interpretation, not a finding established here.

Schmitt asks what it is like inside Musk’s mind and how he handles multiple projects. Musk describes his mind as a storm, then turns to the influences he considers important.

Musk says he grew up in South Africa but was shaped by American comics, games and television. He says those stories gave him an ideal of trying to do useful things and act on the side of what he considers right. Schmitt thanks him and the interview closes.

Schmitt thanks Musk and the interview ends. The recording continues briefly with applause and music.

同じチャンネルの記事