En 30 segundos
In August 2018 testimony to the US Securities and Exchange Commission, Elon Musk described his dispute with Tesla short sellers and the roles he believed he occupied as CEO and potential buyer in a proposed take-private transaction. He said he hoped existing shareholders would remain with a private company. Investigators and counsel debated whether discussions with Tesla’s lawyer were privileged. The SEC’s published transcript supplies questions missing from the video’s automatic captions.
- 1Musk says short sellers circulated information he considered falseHe describes their criticism and his view of its impact on Tesla’s reputation.
- 2Musk links his short-seller tweets to financial and production targetsHe says his expectations centered on reaching 5,000 Model 3s per week and becoming profitable and cash-flow positive.
- 3Musk describes himself as a buyer of shares held by investors who wanted outHe says he hoped to retain the same shareholders after taking the company private.
- 4Investigators ask which role Musk occupied when making statementsMusk distinguishes speaking as Tesla CEO from speaking as a prospective buyer; counsel raises objections about legal capacity.
- 5Lawyers dispute privilege around company-counsel adviceMusk says public posts were fundamentally his own words while acknowledging editing suggestions from counsel.
Conclusiones
- Musk said he hoped existing shareholders would remain invested if Tesla became private.
- He described speaking in different capacities as CEO and prospective buyer during the proposal.
- SEC investigators and lawyers disputed whether questions about advice from Tesla’s general counsel implicated attorney-client privilege.
- The SEC’s written record provides questions missing from the video’s automatic captions.
Lee el texto editado por capítulos
Short sellers and Tesla’s public reputation
Investigators ask Musk about criticism from short sellers and his responses. He describes the impact he believes their activity had on Tesla.
SEC attorney Walker Newell introduces other members of the examination team. He then turns to short sellers and asks whether Musk believes Tesla has been unfairly targeted. The questions in this article are checked against the SEC’s published written transcript (https://www.sec.gov/files/elon-musk-testimony-transcript.pdf); the video’s automatic captions chiefly capture Musk’s responses.
Musk says he considers the criticism unfair because he believes some information circulated to the press and on social media is false. Asked for examples, he cites claims that Tesla is fraudulent, that he is a fraud and that the stock is worth zero; he rejects those assertions.
Newell asks about criticism of Tesla’s financial condition and whether short-seller pressure has grown. Musk says critics have accused Tesla of fraudulent accounting, which he denies. He estimates official short positions of roughly $11 billion to $12 billion and speculates the figure could be higher including other positions.
Asked when the activity intensified, Musk traces it to around the first quarter of 2013. He recalls a high number of days to cover short positions and says he publicly warned that the scale of shorting was unwise.
Musk says the dollar value of short positions increased over the previous two years and alleges that negative publicity increased with it. Asked why Tesla attracts such activity, he says skeptics doubt a new carmaker can compete with larger, better-resourced companies.
Musk recalls that some short sellers expected Tesla to fail in early 2013, while it instead made a small quarterly profit. He says that with two weeks left in the quarter, the company had delivered only half the cars it expected to deliver.
He says he reassigned people across Tesla, including design, human resources and legal staff as well as himself, to help deliver cars. Musk says the vehicles and customers were already there and deliveries doubled in two weeks.
Asked whether continued execution would cause short sellers to leave, Musk says he expects positive cash flow and at least modest profitability to challenge their thesis. He nevertheless thinks short sellers will return and predict failure again.
Asked how he plans to limit their effect, Musk says he is unsure. He claims critics amplify real negative news as well as information he considers false, citing media attention to Tesla crashes as an example.
Musk makes claims about relative vehicle-fire risk and the safety of Tesla models, arguing that news coverage does not convey them. These are his statements during the examination, rather than findings established by the testimony.
Newell asks whether Musk has discussed short sellers on Twitter and about a blogger whose identity is redacted in the SEC’s written transcript. Musk describes seeing the blogger’s articles and posts and says he strongly disagrees with them.
Asked about reports that he contacted someone connected to the blogger, Musk says he sought to understand whether the person agreed with the blogger’s statements. He describes another inquiry to someone he believed was connected to criticism of Tesla. The SEC’s published record redacts names in these exchanges.
Tweets and the proposed private transaction
Musk explains what he meant by short-seller comments and describes his hoped-for shareholder structure if Tesla went private.
Investigators show Musk a printout of an earlier tweet and ask what he meant by a “short burn.” He says a sudden stock-price rise can force short sellers to cover losses, and links his expectation to production and financial milestones.
Musk says he expected Tesla to reach a rate of 5,000 Model 3 vehicles per week and subsequently become profitable and cash-flow positive. He agrees that he expected these developments to affect the stock price.
Shown another tweet about a short position, Musk says it referred specifically to Tesla reaching the 5,000-per-week Model 3 production rate. He says short sellers remained committed to their bankruptcy thesis even after the production milestone.
Asked why he did not wait for news of the production goal to become public and let it affect the stock price, Musk says that, in retrospect, waiting would have been the smarter move.
Newell moves to the proposed take-private transaction and asks about an August 2018 email to the Tesla board. Musk confirms sending an offer and, after some initial uncertainty about the date, accepts the examiner’s reference to August 2.
Asked in what capacity he sent it, Musk describes himself as effectively a buyer, but distinguishes his proposal from a conventional leveraged buyout. He says he expected to buy shares from those who did not want to remain with the company privately, rather than necessarily acquiring the entire company.
Asked about an August 3 board meeting, Musk says he occupied multiple roles. He distinguishes answering operational questions as CEO from answering questions about the proposed transaction as a buyer.
Musk recalls discussing both the company’s condition and the possibility of going private with the board. He agrees that he understood himself to be speaking in different capacities depending on the topic.
Investigators turn to Musk’s August 7 tweets and an email to employees that became a public blog post. The SEC transcript records his answers about the capacity in which he believed he was speaking; his counsel objects that such questions can call for a legal determination.
Public statements and questions of privilege
Investigators review blog posts and ask who drafted them. Counsel and SEC staff discuss the scope of attorney-client privilege.
After reviewing the August 7 blog post, Musk says he understood himself to be writing from the perspective of a buyer. He again says his objective was to keep the existing shareholder base while ending public trading, rather than acquire a large majority through a conventional leveraged buyout.
Asked whether he hoped to avoid making an additional equity investment personally, Musk says his hope was that all existing shareholders would remain with the company. He says Tesla general counsel Todd Maron helped draft the post, and others may have contributed, though he cannot identify their contributions.
The SEC attorney asks what Musk discussed with Maron about the post before publication. The written record shows Musk’s lawyer Steven Farina warning against revealing privileged communications, and company counsel Bradley Bondi instructing Musk not to answer on the basis of Tesla’s attorney-client privilege.
SEC attorney Cheryl Crumpton points to Musk’s testimony that he wrote from the perspective of a prospective counterparty, rather than as Tesla CEO. Bondi responds that the communication was an email from the CEO to employees and maintains that advice about it belongs to the company’s privilege. They agree to continue the discussion separately.
Asked about possible conversations with another executive apart from discussions with Maron, Musk says he does not recall any. He says there may have been email exchanges with another person, but not exchanges of substance.
Investigators then review a second Tesla blog post, published August 13. Musk recognizes it and comments on its frequent use of the first person. Asked about the capacity in which he authorized it, he says he believed he was acting as a buyer, not as Tesla’s CEO.
Musk says he generally writes his own blog posts and that the substance was his own, though counsel helped and offered corrections and additions. He says he regarded the post as an accurate statement of the facts.
Asked which lawyers were involved, Musk names Steve Rosenblum and says the post also likely went through Tesla’s company counsel, Todd Maron. He is unsure who else saw it.
SEC attorney Steven Buchholz asks what Musk discussed with Maron. Farina says the company has asserted privilege and advises Musk to respect it. Bondi says legal advice surrounding the company’s public disclosure is protected; Crumpton questions the claim, and the lawyers discuss how to proceed.
Crumpton asks whether Musk contemplated litigation when the August 13 post was drafted. Musk says Tesla was frequently involved in litigation and cites a recent case concerning its production statements. Counsel and investigators continue to disagree over whether related questions would reveal privileged advice.
Asked whether Maron represented him personally, independently of Tesla, Musk says he does not believe so. The attorneys continue to distinguish Musk’s personal understanding from legal advice he may have received in his role at the company.
Musk says his recollection is that Maron was careful to represent Tesla rather than Musk individually as a buyer. He says he does not believe Maron represented him personally when he should have been representing the company. Farina then calls for a break.
Más de este canal
59:13EN
1:08:00EN
1:00:50EN