In 30 seconds
Elon Musk told SEC investigators that he understood Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund to be ready to support a Tesla take-private on reasonable terms. He also acknowledged that the terms had not been worked out and that he could not recall the precise words used. He described subsequent conversations with Egon Durban and Michael Dell, his expectation that existing shareholders would remain, and the operational risks that ultimately weighed against going private. The SEC’s published written transcript supplies questions missing from the video’s automatic captions.
- 1Musk recalls support subject to reasonable termsHe described his understanding of the fund’s position, but said the terms were not worked out and he could not recall the exact wording.
- 2A diversified investor base was Musk’s preferenceHe told Egon Durban he hoped most shareholders would stay and wanted additional investors to avoid excessive influence from one holder.
- 3He later recognized a misunderstanding about small shareholdersMusk said he had wrongly assumed a way could be found for retail investors to retain their stakes.
- 4Short-term execution risk weighed against the proposalMusk worried the transaction could distract Tesla from cash-flow and profitability targets.
Takeaways
- Musk said the fund’s prior investment and its representatives’ comments convinced him financing was available, although specific terms had not been agreed.
- He recalled seeking a diversified investor base and later realizing he had misunderstood the difficulty of retaining small shareholders.
- He weighed potential long-term relief against transaction costs, short-term distraction and the risk of investors with conflicting objectives.
Read the edited text by chapter
The July 31 meeting
Musk recalls who attended the meeting and how he interpreted the Saudi fund’s investment and interest.
Investigators continue asking about Musk’s July 31 meeting with Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund (PIF). The SEC’s published written transcript supplies questions absent from the video’s automatic captions: https://www.sec.gov/files/elon-musk-testimony-transcript.pdf.
Musk recalls Sam Teller joining somewhere around one-third or halfway through the meeting, though he cannot pin down the moment or whether he asked him to join.
He says that, if Teller had not already been present, he would have asked him to join once the discussion turned to the fund’s investment in Tesla.
Musk recalls speaking briefly alone with the fund’s managing director, Yasir Al-Rumayyan, as he left the room. He estimates the meeting lasted about 40 minutes.
Asked about documents, Musk says he does not recall receiving anything and is quite sure he received nothing highly sensitive.
Musk says the fund disclosed that it had bought a multibillion-dollar stake in Tesla, approaching the 5% reporting threshold. He says this was new information to him.
He says the fund had previously indicated an intention to invest and had done so without a written agreement. That history, in his view, gave him confidence in its representatives’ word.
Musk says he understood the fund to want to take Tesla private, and to be willing to proceed on terms he proposed within reasonable bounds. He says he believed the financing was secure.
He recalls discussion that a larger investment would involve a larger strategic role, such as factories, and describes the fund as asking how he wanted to proceed.
Pressed on the wording, Musk says his account is a paraphrase: he recalls being told to say how he wanted to do the transaction, subject to something like reasonable terms.
He says the fund’s existing investment and resources led him to believe support was available if he chose to pursue the deal.
What reasonable terms meant
Investigators press Musk on his recollection of the fund’s language and the terms left to be determined.
Musk says he cannot provide the exact words. Asked about “reasonable,” he says it may have been that word or a synonym, and that its meaning was not discussed in detail.
He says the next step was for him to state his desired terms. Investigators ask whether those terms had been ironed out at the meeting; he says they had not.
Musk nevertheless describes his understanding as a deal that could proceed unless his demands were outside the bounds of a normal take-private. He says this was not intended as a narrow definition of reasonableness.
He points again to the fund’s existing investment as the basis for his confidence. His testimony describes his understanding of the fund’s intentions, rather than a signed agreement on transaction terms.
Musk gives hypothetical examples of demands he thinks might have been unacceptable, including an extreme price premium or unusual voting rights.
He says he did not believe the fund had a minimum ownership requirement, reasoning from its existing stake and the explanation he says he received about the reporting threshold.
Musk recalls a brief exchange with Al-Rumayyan as the meeting ended: in his recollection, the fund reiterated its interest, and Musk said he would get back to him.
The week before the tweet
Musk recalls conversations with advisers and others, while distinguishing what he did and did not remember.
Asked about subsequent conversations, Musk says he probably spoke briefly with colleagues, but cannot recall substantive details. He distinguishes that from a later conversation with Egon Durban.
Investigators move to the period from August 1 through the morning of August 7. Musk asks for documents to help anchor the dates.
He recalls speaking with Michael Dell about Dell’s experience of being private, with lawyer Steve Rosenblum, and with Silver Lake’s Egon Durban on the Monday before the tweet.
Musk says he probably discussed the pros and cons of a take-private and a larger Saudi investment with Sam Teller, but does not recall a substantive discussion with Deepak Ahuja.
Asked about further contact with the fund before the tweet, Musk says a text was possible but he does not remember a substantive exchange or a phone call.
He says he had not retained advisers in the period between the July 31 meeting and the morning of August 7. Investigators then turn to his communications with Durban.
Shown a record of messages, Musk recognizes the content. Investigators use the messages to establish the timing of a call with Durban.
Egon Durban and potential investors
Musk describes conversations about financing, investor diversity and existing shareholders.
Musk recalls meeting Durban at SpaceX earlier in 2018 and mentioning that he had long wanted to consider taking Tesla private. Durban invited him to call if he became serious about it.
At that earlier meeting, Musk says, Durban provided a document identifying potential investors. Musk understood it as Durban’s opinion about interest, rather than a commitment from those investors.
Musk says he told Durban that the Saudis wanted to support a transaction, but that he preferred a broader investor base rather than concentrating too much ownership in one investor.
He recalls mentioning a possible Saudi stake of about 15% to 20% as his own preference, while expecting many existing investors to stay. He asked about bringing in other investors.
According to Musk, Durban was confident other investors would be interested. Musk says Durban did not convey that he had already spoken to them about this transaction.
Musk says Durban initially approached the idea more like a conventional buyout, in which most outside shareholders might be bought out. Musk says he objected to forcing small investors to sell.
He describes his aim as reducing distractions while building cars and scaling Tesla, rather than increasing his own ownership. He compares the pressures on a public company with his experience at SpaceX.
Musk recalls Durban saying that retaining many investors could reduce the amount of new capital needed. That assessment depended on Musk’s expectation that shareholders would remain.
Musk says the difficulty of keeping non-wealthy retail investors in a private company was not raised in that discussion. He acknowledges that his earlier assumption that a means could be found was a fundamental misunderstanding.
Deciding whether to proceed
He discusses legal advice, the share price, execution risks and the eventual decision to remain public.
Musk says he believes he spoke with lawyer Steve Rosenblum on the Saturday before the tweet and describes him as potential lead or co-lead counsel, while expressing uncertainty about the exact timing.
Asked when he decided to make an offer, Musk is uncertain whether the relevant email was written on a Friday or Wednesday. He connects the decision with sending the email.
Musk says the market’s response to Tesla’s earnings call was one factor in deciding whether a take-private would be feasible. A very large spike in the share price could make the transaction impractical.
He gives hypothetical examples of a steep rise and explains that adding a takeover premium on top of a price spike could exceed what would be reasonable for a buyer.
Musk says major decisions involve many small factors and that he finds it useful to sleep on them. A large spike might have required waiting for the price to settle.
He also worried that managing a take-private would create short-term overhead and distract Tesla from its targets for positive cash flow and profitability in the coming quarters.
Musk describes weighing months of greater effort against possible relief in later years. He says it was hard to predict the burden or how a transition to a private-company model would work.
He worried that private investors could make onerous demands or have strategic interests that conflicted with the company’s goals.
He recalls his experience at Zip2, where newspaper-company investors sat on the board. In his view, some of their strategic objectives were not aligned with the company’s.
Musk contrasts that experience with SpaceX, where he says there is less pressure around quarterly boundaries and fewer shareholder lawsuits following setbacks.
He says the uncertainty made the proposal worth investigating, but the balance changed. In his account, remaining public was ultimately probably the right decision, even if it was not ideal.
More from this channel
59:13EN
1:00:50EN
52:05EN