Elon Musk in 2009: Building Tesla’s Battery and SpaceX’s Rocket

Musk explains the engineering behind Tesla’s battery packs and SpaceX’s rockets, and the financial pressure facing both companies.

EMElon MuskGuest · Tesla and SpaceX
Channel
Elon Musk best videos
Published
Nov 6, 2015
Video
1:32:59
Read
12 min
Original
English
Open on YouTube
Scroll to read and the video shrinks to the bottom-right corner. Captions follow your reading language.
Reading languageAvailable in 2 languages
You're reading the original English.
SUMMARY

In 30 seconds

In 2009, Elon Musk described Tesla’s attempt to turn thousands of laptop-type cells into a safe car battery, while developing the lower-priced Model S. He said the Roadster had once cost $140,000 to build against a $92,000 selling price, leaving the company in a severe cash squeeze. At SpaceX, he outlined Falcon 9 and Dragon’s planned missions and argued that NASA’s purchase of a delivery service gave the company room to design its own vehicle. Many of the car specifications and spaceflight dates were still goals.

  1. 1A battery pack needed protection at several levelsMusk describes cell checks and fuses, modules that resist heat spreading, and liquid cooling. The whole pack also had to survive vibration, crashes and temperature extremes for years.
  2. 2The proposed Model S base price and range came with conditionsMusk quotes $49,900 after a federal tax credit for a planned 160-mile version, with a larger 300-mile pack offered separately. He also describes fast charging and battery swapping as planned solutions.
  3. 3The early Roadster cost far more to build than its selling priceMusk says the car cost $140,000 against a $92,000 price and still faced technical and testing problems. Tesla was close to running out of money at the end of 2007.
  4. 4SpaceX’s cargo schedule still depended on testing and NASA requirementsMusk hoped to begin operational resupply at the end of the following year, but acknowledged that safety requirements could delay the missions and that NASA had contingencies.
  5. 5Nine engines were intended to allow a rocket to survive an engine failureMusk says multiple engines provide redundancy if a failure is prevented from spreading. The design also had to deliver the payload customers needed.
  6. 6NASA’s earlier demonstration contract helped SpaceX win cargo workMusk credits six years of work and NASA’s financial and advisory support under the COTS program with helping the company compete for resupply missions.

Takeaways

  1. Musk said Tesla’s Roadster once cost $140,000 to make while selling for $92,000.
  2. Battery safety required multiple layers: cell checks and fuses, barriers to heat spreading, and liquid cooling.
  3. The proposed $49,900 Model S price was after a federal tax credit, with a 160-mile base range; 300 miles required a larger pack.
  4. Musk argued multiple Falcon 9 engines could provide redundancy if an engine failure could be contained.
  5. NASA’s cargo contract purchased a delivery service rather than prescribing the spacecraft design, Musk said.
FULL TEXT

Read the edited text by chapter

Transcript only
01

Roadster orders, funding and factory plans

Musk describes the Roadster’s sales backlog and Tesla’s planned federal loan. He also discusses where Tesla builds the car and how loan requirements influence factory choices.

Churchill Club CEO Karen Tucker welcomes the audience and introduces journalist Michael Malone, who has covered Silicon Valley for more than 25 years. Malone introduces Elon Musk and asks about Tesla Motors.

Musk says the Roadster is sold out through October and expects all 2009 production to sell out within a few months. A Roadster Sport is also coming: he quotes zero to 60 mph in 3.7 seconds and says many buyers with later delivery slots are choosing the upgrade.

Musk compares the Roadster’s price with a gasoline sports car after accounting for a $7,500 federal electric-vehicle tax credit and a gas-guzzler tax that an electric car avoids. He puts the comparable base price just under $100,000 and the Sport package at an additional $20,000.

Tesla previously used customer deposits as financing, with customers told that their deposits were at risk. Musk says the company no longer needs as much of that funding and plans to reduce the deposit to $9,900, with the balance due at the start of production, a couple of months before delivery.

Falling gasoline prices have not been a major factor in Roadster orders, Musk thinks, since people do not buy a $100,000 sports car mainly to save on fuel. The wider economic downturn and loss of customer wealth have affected demand, though the company has a roughly six-month backlog.

Musk says Tesla has not yet taken government money, but is seeking a Department of Energy loan under the Advanced Technology Vehicles Manufacturing program. He distinguishes that program from the later bailout and stimulus measures and says he is optimistic about approval in the near term.

The proposed San Jose factory site was considered before the federal loan program passed, Musk explains. He says its preference for older manufacturing facilities complicates building on undeveloped land. Tesla has examined two Southern California sites; he would like to acquire the NUMMI plant in the Bay Area if it became available and affordable.

Roadsters receive final assembly and powertrain installation in Menlo Park, with battery packs made in San Carlos and high-speed tests at Moffett Field. Musk says production is about 25 cars a week and might rise to 30 in summer.

02

Making thousands of cells safe in the Model S

Musk outlines layers of battery protection and the engineering needed for a durable pack. He presents Model S range, seating, screens and charging as design goals.

Musk describes the newly unveiled Model S as an attempt to make a mass-produced, highway-capable electric car. He stresses that it is still an aspiration until Tesla actually produces it at scale. The battery is a large flat pack between the axles, made from laptop-type cells.

A cell’s chemistry and the engineering of a battery pack are different problems, Musk says. The pack needs mechanical, electrical and software engineering to manage many cells. He says Tesla makes large lithium-ion packs and is supplying a pack for Daimler’s electric Smart car.

Asked whether thousands of cells could overheat, Musk describes several layers of protection. Tesla checks the cells, adds fuses, and builds modules to keep a failing cell’s heat from spreading to its neighbors even if active systems fail.

The pack is also liquid cooled. Musk says the challenge is to conduct heat away while keeping the system electrically isolated and durable through years of vibration, potholes, temperature extremes and crashes. It must also be affordable, pass regulations and preserve battery life.

For Model S, Musk describes a planned range of up to 300 miles and seating for five adults plus optional rear-facing seats for two children. He says Tesla aims for a five-star crash rating and expects the battery in the floor to lower the center of gravity and reduce rollover risk compared with an SUV.

The planned Model S interior centers on a 17-inch touchscreen, which Musk compares to a large iPhone, with a separate driver display. He describes internet access, a browser, possible voice controls and customizable displays, and says he would like outside developers to be able to make applications.

Tesla is targeting 20,000 Model S cars a year, split between domestic and international sales. Musk says that would take only a small share of the market for premium sedans. He quotes a starting price of $49,900 after the federal tax credit.

The quoted base model is planned for 160 miles of range; a more expensive pack could reach 300 miles. Musk discusses renting a larger pack for occasional long trips, 45-minute fast charging, and designing the battery so special equipment could exchange it more quickly than filling a gas tank.

Musk thinks it is most efficient to put solar panels on a house, generating power during daytime peak demand, and charge the car at night. He also discusses possible panels on the car or solar carports, and the more speculative idea of coating the car with photovoltaic material.

03

Why Tesla chose an electric car and how it survived

Musk explains the battery, weight and drivetrain tradeoffs behind Tesla’s decision against a plug-in hybrid. He recounts the Roadster’s cost and technical problems and the company’s near cash shortage.

Tesla considered a plug-in hybrid but decided to concentrate on electric vehicles. Musk says he hopes GM’s Volt succeeds; he is explaining Tesla’s engineering choice rather than predicting the failure of another approach.

His argument is that a smaller battery in a range-extended car must deliver high power relative to its energy capacity. In his estimate, the resulting pack might be 40–50% the size of a 200-mile pack, not one-fifth. Adding an engine, generator, connections and maintenance for two drivetrains then adds weight and cost.

Musk also worries that a small engine would be strained once the battery’s electric range is exhausted. Given a fixed cost and mass, he thinks a design optimized for either gasoline or electricity may work better than splitting the compromise between them, while acknowledging that he could be wrong.

Malone asks how Tesla found Ze’ev Drori, its former CEO and vice chairman. Musk says an investor introduced them. Drori was an entrepreneur and racing enthusiast who was willing to enter a difficult situation at the end of 2007, when few people wanted the job.

Musk says Tesla discovered the Roadster cost $140,000 to make while it was being sold for $92,000. The transmission and other technical issues meant the car was not yet ready to pass safety, reliability and endurance tests, and the company was close to running out of money.

Musk says he and Drori effectively ran Tesla together while Drori learned its background. As the financial crisis intensified and Musk increased his financial commitment, Musk took on the full CEO role. He then quotes planned Model S performance: roughly 5.5 seconds from zero to 60 mph, with a faster sport version envisioned.

04

From South Africa to Zip2

Musk recounts moving through Canada to the United States, studying physics and business, and leaving Stanford to start an internet company. He and his brother slept in their office during Zip2’s early days.

Asked about leaving South Africa at 17, Musk says he wanted to reach the United States and did not want to be conscripted into the South African army. His mother’s Canadian birth enabled him to obtain Canadian citizenship; after roughly three years in Canada, he continued his education at the University of Pennsylvania.

Unsure how quickly he could find work, Musk tested whether he could eat for under a dollar a day by buying hot dogs, oranges, pasta and sauce in bulk. He says the diet was monotonous, but it would have stretched his limited savings.

Musk says engineering and design were his main interests, but he studied business as well as physics so he could understand business decisions. He corrects Malone’s description of his planned Stanford research: it was at the intersection of applied physics and materials science, including whether a capacitor could store energy at a density approaching a battery’s.

He left the Stanford program after two days to start an internet business in 1995. He says his initial aim was to earn enough to live, not to become wealthy, and that he began Zip2 before Netscape went public. He also says he had tried unsuccessfully to get a job at Netscape.

Musk says he persuaded his brother to come from Canada and join him. They rented office space rather than an apartment, slept on futons that became meeting-room couches by day, and showered at the YMCA. The arrangement also let them work out there.

05

Audience questions about Tesla and Detroit

Musk explains the Tesla name and gives his assessment of Detroit’s carmakers. He contrasts Tesla’s planned sedan with Fisker’s plug-in hybrid.

During audience questions, one attendee suggests having a car read messages in the sender’s voice. Asked about Tesla’s name, Musk says the company was named for Nikola Tesla; he recalls Michael Faraday as another name considered.

On Detroit’s automakers, Musk expects a smaller industry after the financial crisis and thinks management and labor both need substantial reform. He argues that great products must be the foundation of recovery. Asked about a possible GM purchase of Tesla, he questions whether GM has the cash or valuable equity to pay for it.

Asked to compare Tesla and Fisker, Musk says Fisker is pursuing a plug-in hybrid and a sportier sedan, while Model S is intended to carry five adults, potentially two children and luggage. He repeats that the companies are following different strategies and quotes their proposed price points.

06

SpaceX’s early cargo contract and plans for Mars

Musk describes the NASA resupply contract and the uncertain schedule for Falcon 9 and Dragon. He recounts how interest in a Mars mission led him toward spaceflight.

Musk says he divides his working time roughly evenly between SpaceX and Tesla, though a crisis can shift the balance sharply in a given week. He says SpaceX has been profitable and cash-flow positive for two and a half years, reached orbit the previous year, and received a $1.6 billion NASA cargo resupply contract.

The first operational cargo mission is then planned for the end of the following year, after demonstrations. Musk says SpaceX has a decent chance of meeting that schedule, but NASA safety requirements could affect it; the agency has contingencies if SpaceX is late.

Musk says that in college he thought space travel, clean energy and the internet would strongly affect humanity, but did not expect to work in space himself because of its cost. After PayPal, he began considering a philanthropic project to generate public support for sending people to Mars.

He recalls looking for a NASA Mars plan and finding none, then exploring possible projects with Adeo, including trips to Russia to investigate buying refurbished missiles. Musk criticizes the shuttle as a step away from travel beyond low Earth orbit and says he would have preferred improving on the Saturn V.

For SpaceX, the next major milestone is the first Falcon 9 launch, which Musk hopes will happen around the end of summer. He estimates about $40 million per Falcon 9 flight, roughly as much again for a Dragon spacecraft, plus NASA-related costs. An upcoming Falcon 1 flight is planned to carry a Malaysian Earth-observation satellite.

Musk hopes to launch Dragon on Falcon 9 later that year for orbital maneuvers and reentry, and to reach the space station the following year. He says the cargo contract runs approximately to 2015 and might be extended. These are plans and estimates he gives during the 2009 event.

NASA remains essential, Musk says: it is SpaceX’s largest customer. He describes a change in the contracting model: instead of specifying the vehicle’s design, NASA is purchasing a cargo-delivery service and leaving design decisions to the contractor.

07

Engine redundancy and crew safety

An audience question prompts Musk to explain Falcon 9’s multiple engines. He describes Dragon’s intended escape system and his preference for a blunt capsule over the shuttle’s winged design.

A student asks why Falcon 9 uses nine Merlin engines rather than one larger engine. Musk says multiple engines can provide the ability to continue a mission after an engine fails, provided a failure cannot spread to the others. Nine also met the payload requirements of SpaceX’s customers, he says.

Musk compares the approach to using many computers rather than a few large mainframes, and to the thousands of cells in a Tesla battery. He says vertical liftoff makes engine-out capability especially demanding because thrust must remain greater than the rocket’s weight.

Dragon is being designed to meet NASA’s crew safety requirements, Musk says, including structural margins, redundancy and limits during aborts. A key item still to finish is a launch escape system that can carry the capsule away if the booster fails.

Musk criticizes the shuttle’s lack of an ascent escape system and argues that its winged shape presents reentry risks. He favors a blunt capsule that can be naturally stable during reentry and protected by a broad heat shield. He says that, until US crew transport is available, Russian Soyuz vehicles will carry astronauts.

08

Managing competing demands and exploring space

Musk discusses balancing family and two companies, then answers questions about capsule landings, suborbital flight and why he values a multiplanetary future.

Asked how he manages both companies and family, Musk says ordinary weeks are manageable, but overlapping crises can become overwhelming. He compares his approach to triage: deciding which urgent problem needs attention first.

An audience member asks whether wings are needed for a controlled landing. Musk argues that a capsule can generate enough lift to steer by offsetting its center of mass. He says parachute steering or other controls could further improve landing accuracy, though these are possibilities he is describing rather than demonstrated Dragon capabilities.

SpaceX did not build SpaceShipOne, Musk says. He served as an X Prize Foundation trustee and contributed some funding to the prize it won. He distinguishes suborbital flight from orbital flight: reaching orbit requires far more speed and therefore much more kinetic energy.

Asked why a multiplanetary existence matters, Musk compares it to major transitions in the history of life, such as the move from oceans to land. He considers a self-sustaining settlement beyond Earth extraordinarily difficult but worth a modest share of society’s resources.

09

NASA’s support, prizes and speculative ideas

Musk credits NASA’s earlier demonstration program with helping SpaceX compete for cargo missions. He also discusses SolarCity, research prizes, robotics and ideas he is not yet pursuing.

Musk says SolarCity, run by his cousins Peter and Lyndon Rive, provides solar systems for homes and small businesses. He is chairman and offers strategic and product advice, but says the company requires little of his day-to-day time.

Asked how SpaceX won NASA’s confidence, Musk says it took about six years of work. He credits the earlier Commercial Orbital Transportation Services demonstration contract with financial and advisory support that helped SpaceX compete for the cargo resupply contract.

When Malone asks what else he thinks about, Musk mentions fusion, prefabricated double-deck highways and a supersonic electric aircraft. He calls fusion particularly difficult and stresses that these are speculative ideas, not projects he is announcing.

Musk supports prizes for outcomes, including a possible battery technology prize: a prize can reward a result without a committee having to select the winning technical approach in advance. He points to automotive, genomics and lunar X Prizes and DARPA’s autonomous-vehicle challenges.

On robotics, Musk says Tesla already uses some automation to assemble battery packs and expects more in mass production. He also values robotic Mars exploration and preparation, while maintaining that his longer-term aim is to extend life itself beyond Earth.

10

Public attention and the work Musk prefers

Musk says he is concerned about false stories reaching his children. He describes himself as introverted and says he prefers engineering and design to publicity.

Malone asks how Musk handles increasing public attention. Musk says he dislikes false or trivial stories, especially if his children might read them. He describes himself as naturally introverted and says engineering and design are what he prefers, although selling cars also requires public promotion.

Asked for a final thought, Musk wishes for luck for the companies. Malone thanks him, and Karen Tucker closes the Churchill Club event.

More from this channel

13:40EN
Elon Musk best videos· Dec 11, 2015Elon Musk’s 2014 plan for affordable Teslas and a city on MarsGuest Elon MuskMusk said costly early cars would fund a cheaper Tesla, while Mars settlement would require a dramatic fall in travel costs.TeslaElectric VehiclesSpaceX+1
28:23EN
Elon Musk best videos· Dec 8, 2015Elon Musk in 2011: Reusable Rockets, NASA and SpaceX’s First Crew PlansGuest Elon MuskDuring a visit to SpaceX’s Hawthorne factory, Musk discusses the cost of spaceflight, Dragon’s design and his long-term ambition for Mars.SpaceXInfrastructure & deploymentEntrepreneurship+1
1:10:16EN
Elon Musk best videos· Dec 6, 2015Tesla’s 2010 bet on Model S: rising spending before mass productionHost Ricardo ReyesOn the third-quarter call, Musk and CFO Deepak Ahuja laid out the sedan’s milestones, finances and automaker partnerships.TeslaElectric Vehicles
23:36EN
Elon Musk best videos· Dec 6, 2015Musk’s 2010 plan for Model S, an SUV and a cheaper TeslaGuest Elon MuskBefore Model S production, Musk outlined development milestones, charging choices and the next vehicles on Tesla’s roadmap.TeslaElectric VehiclesProduct Strategy
24:50EN
Elon Musk best videos· Dec 4, 2015Elon Musk on Leaving PayPal and Preparing SpaceX’s Fourth LaunchGuest Elon MuskBefore Falcon 1’s fourth flight, Musk explains the PayPal dispute, Tesla’s Roadster decisions and SpaceX’s early launch failures.SpaceXTeslaEntrepreneurship+2
31:15EN
Elon Musk best videos· Nov 27, 2015Elon Musk in 2010: Tesla’s Early Strategy, Funding and Entrepreneurial AdviceGuest Elon Musk · Host Bambi FranciscoIn a Vator interview, Musk explains the Roadster-to-Model S strategy, early financing and the questions he believes founders should ask themselves.TeslaSpaceXElectric Vehicles+2