In 30 seconds
In 2010, Elon Musk argued that NASA needed commercial transportation to make human spaceflight affordable without an Apollo-sized budget increase. Obama’s proposal would cancel Constellation, use private firms for trips to low Earth orbit and develop technology for deeper missions. Howard McCurdy saw a large gamble on lower costs, while Bill Adkins warned that fixed-price development contracts were hard to design before requirements were clear. A caller’s failed financing effort prompted Musk to support milestone-based competition, with a clearer promise of future business.
- 1Obama proposed bypassing a Moon return for deeper-space goalsMcCurdy compares the proposed leap with Kennedy’s choice to aim for the Moon; Adkins says the speech added missing destinations and timelines.
- 2Musk saw commercial transport as a way to make the plan affordableHe argued NASA could not count on an Apollo-sized budget increase and likened SpaceX to a manufacturer and airline combined.
- 3The cost promise and fixed-price contracts carried risksMcCurdy questioned whether competition could achieve the projected cost reduction. Adkins warned that fixed prices are difficult before requirements are understood.
- 4A failed financing effort exposed a contract-design problemA Rocketplane Kistler caller describes missing a financing milestone. Musk supports NASA recompeting the funds but says successful developers should have clearer future business.
- 5Orbiting Mars and landing there are different challengesAdkins says entry, descent and landing make a human landing substantially more difficult than a mission to Mars orbit.
Takeaways
- Musk argued in 2010 that commercial transport could make NASA’s human-spaceflight ambitions affordable.
- McCurdy identified the central gamble as whether competition could deliver crew-launch capability at a much lower cost.
- Adkins warned that fixed-price development is difficult when technical requirements and risks remain unclear.
- Musk supported milestone-based competition but wanted successful developers to have a clearer prospect of government orders.
Read the edited text by chapter
A new direction for NASA
Obama’s 2010 proposal would replace Constellation and use commercial firms for near-Earth transportation. The panel considers its deeper-space goals.
Ira Flatow introduces President Obama’s 2010 plan for NASA: private companies would carry out trips to low Earth orbit while NASA developed technology for deeper space. Obama proposed cancelling the Constellation program and its Ares rockets rather than returning astronauts to the Moon first.
Flatow says the proposal has divided astronauts: Neil Armstrong and others criticized it, while Buzz Aldrin supported it. He asks guests Howard McCurdy, Bill Adkins and SpaceX CEO Elon Musk what the change means for human spaceflight.
Musk says Obama’s visit to SpaceX’s launch complex was a surprise: the company learned of it only the day before. He sees the visit as a sign of support, while saying he cannot speak for the president’s reasons.
McCurdy says people who feared cuts to human spaceflight needed reassurance. He compares Obama’s decision to pursue deeper space with John F. Kennedy’s decision to leapfrog intermediate achievements and aim for the Moon.
Obama’s speech set a goal of sending people to orbit Mars and return safely in the 2030s, with a landing to follow. McCurdy links the proposal to the flexible path described in the Augustine report.
Adkins says the speech supplied destinations and timetables that critics had found missing. In his view it balances near-term activity involving commercial firms with investment in technology for the longer journey.
The host plays Obama’s proposal to send astronauts to an asteroid as an early deep-space mission. Adkins says such a mission is easier than landing on the Moon because the Moon has a deeper gravity well; asteroids are also scientifically interesting.
Commercial transport and its risks
Musk argues that private transport could make progress affordable. McCurdy and Adkins examine cost estimates and contract design.
Musk says commercial space transport, not just SpaceX, is central to the plan. He argues that NASA is unlikely to receive an Apollo-era budget increase, so progress must be affordable and private enterprise should help supply transportation.
Musk compares SpaceX to an aircraft manufacturer and airline combined: it would build the vehicle and operate the mission for a customer such as NASA.
Asked about military launches, Musk says commercial vehicles already carry defense and NASA satellites. He names the Atlas and Delta rockets operated by United Launch Alliance, formed from Boeing and Lockheed Martin launch businesses; the proposed change extends a service-purchasing approach to human spaceflight.
McCurdy compares NASA purchasing transportation to the government’s earlier shift away from using the military to deliver mail. He says the big risk is whether competition can produce a new crew-launch capability for the much lower cost advocates anticipate.
Adkins argues that debating labels such as commercial and government misses the implementation details. Fixed-price contracts for complex development can be difficult when requirements and technical risks are not yet well understood, he says.
Adkins expects more detail through NASA and congressional hearings. He says the choices are not limited to a government-led program or outsourcing everything: there is considerable room between them.
Heavy lift, jobs and a failed financing bid
A caller questions the heavy-lift plan; another describes losing a NASA award after failing to raise the required private funding.
A caller asks why the plan cancels a heavy-lift rocket while still aiming for Mars. Flatow notes that Obama proposed more than $3 billion for advanced heavy-lift research; Adkins says the plan defers locking in a design while investing in areas such as propulsion.
On aerospace jobs, Adkins says there is no painless way through the resource constraints. He argues that a sustainable, achievable program can create more jobs over the long run.
A caller associated with Rocketplane Kistler describes winning an early NASA cargo-development award but failing to secure the required private financing during the financial crisis. He says his firm had raised $350 million of the $500 million required before NASA cancelled its agreement.
The caller argues that the commercial approach can work, but that investors wanted a clearer order book. He points to anticipated private demand and later NASA cargo contracts as evidence of a larger potential market.
Milestones, the shuttle and Mars
Musk defends competition based on milestones while proposing a clearer promise of future orders. The guests consider the shuttle, Congress and the difficulty of landing on Mars.
Musk calls the competition an example of healthy government contracting. He says SpaceX met agreed milestones while Rocketplane Kistler did not, so NASA recompeted the funds and awarded them to Orbital Sciences.
Musk agrees the structure could improve: a company completing the milestones should have a clearer guarantee of subsequent government business. Nevertheless, he prefers a process that ends an unsuccessful arrangement instead of prolonging it.
Flatow asks what Obama meant by a post-Hubble telescope. The guests think he may have meant the James Webb telescope, while noting the possibility of other missions; they do not resolve the ambiguity.
The panel notes that Obama did not discuss extending the space shuttle program. McCurdy connects the speech to political pressure in Florida and expects Congress to shape details while generally following the president’s direction.
Adkins calls the proposal a radical change from Constellation but also a return to principles in the 2004 space vision. He stresses that landing on Mars is far harder than orbiting it, citing the difficulty of entry, descent and landing.
The guests note that the administration’s fact sheet also includes robotic missions, although the speech emphasized human exploration. Adkins says the speech supplied substantive goals missing from the original budget rollout.
Musk says Obama is maintaining the major changes proposed in the budget: cancel Constellation, develop competitive commercial transport and invest in technology for Mars and beyond. In 2010, he calls it the best human-spaceflight policy since Apollo and believes it has a chance of significant success.
Flatow closes by thanking the guests and wishing SpaceX luck with the Falcon 9 launch then planned for the following month.
More from this channel
13:40EN
28:23EN
1:10:16EN
23:36EN
24:50EN
31:15EN