Why a Tesla shareholder challenged Musk’s 2018 pay award

In January 2024, lawyer Greg Varallo explained the disclosure and board-process concerns behind the Delaware ruling.

MCMax Chafkin게스트 · BloombergGVGreg Varallo게스트 · Bernstein Litowitz Berger & Grossmann
채널
Bloomberg Tech
게시일
2024년 1월 31일
영상
9:38
읽기
3분
원문
영어
YouTube에서 열기
스크롤하면 영상이 오른쪽 아래로 작아져 계속 재생됩니다. 자막은 읽기 언어를 따릅니다.
읽기 언어2개 언어로 읽을 수 있음
이 글은 아직 한국어 번역이 없어 영어 원문으로 표시합니다.
요약

30초 요약

After a Delaware judge rescinded Elon Musk’s 2018 Tesla pay award in January 2024, shareholder lawyer Greg Varallo argued that its extraordinary size and misleading disclosures justified scrutiny despite shareholder approval. Bloomberg’s Max Chafkin discussed the implications for Tesla’s board and its ability to retain Musk. The case did not end there: in December 2025, Delaware’s Supreme Court reversed the rescission remedy and reinstated the 2018 plan, awarding nominal damages.

  1. 1The award’s size prompted the shareholder challengeVarallo says the estimated $55 billion package stood far above comparable executive awards, drawing the lawyers’ attention.
  2. 2The lawyer argues the 2018 vote relied on misleading disclosuresVarallo says the trial court found the proxy materially misleading, and argues that shareholders need material facts to make an informed decision.
  3. 3Existing Tesla shares were already an incentive, Varallo saysHe says Musk’s existing stake could have gained tens of billions in value if Tesla met the goals, without extra options.
  4. 4The later appeal reinstated the 2018 planIn December 2025 Delaware’s Supreme Court reversed rescission and awarded nominal damages. The interview was recorded before that decision.

핵심 정리

  1. Varallo said the trial court found material problems in disclosures to shareholders who approved the 2018 award.
  2. He argued Musk’s existing Tesla shares already provided a large incentive to increase the company’s value.
  3. A change in incorporation requires board and shareholder action, Varallo said.
  4. In December 2025 the Delaware Supreme Court reinstated the award after reversing the rescission remedy.
전문

챕터별로 다듬은 전문 읽기

원본 자막만 보기
01

A ruling raises questions about Tesla’s future

Varallo expects an appeal, while Chafkin considers how the ruling may affect Tesla and Musk’s other ventures.

Asked whether Tesla would appeal the Delaware ruling, shareholder lawyer Greg Varallo says an appeal to the Delaware Supreme Court would not surprise him. He explains that the court has the final word on Delaware law.

Bloomberg reporter Max Chafkin says the decision affects not only the value of Musk’s unexercised options but also Tesla’s task of retaining its chief executive. He points to Musk’s earlier comments about pursuing some AI work outside Tesla without greater control, and notes Musk’s other ventures.

Chafkin adds that the decision follows Musk’s Delaware litigation over his purchase of Twitter. The hosts then ask Varallo why he and Tesla shareholder Richard Tornetta challenged the 2018 award.

02

Size, shareholder approval and disclosure

The plaintiff’s lawyer explains why the award drew scrutiny and why he says the shareholder vote did not settle the disclosure problem.

Varallo says the package’s extraordinary size prompted scrutiny: at an estimated $55 billion, it stood far above other executive awards. He says the nearest comparison was an earlier Musk compensation plan.

A host points out that a large majority of voting shareholders approved the package in 2018 and that Tesla’s share price subsequently rose. He asks why the court should intervene when many investors supported the award.

Varallo responds that shareholder approval depends on material information being disclosed. He says the trial court found the proxy statement materially misleading in several respects, which in his view undermined the significance of the vote.

03

Board independence and the value of existing shares

Chafkin discusses directors’ ties to Musk. Varallo argues that the existing stake already gave Musk a strong incentive to grow Tesla.

Asked about the board, Chafkin says several nominally independent directors had close personal ties to Musk. He considers it unclear what the decision will mean for the board and speculates that the dispute could increase the risk of Musk threatening to leave, while describing an actual departure as a remote possibility.

The host asks why a founder should not receive a large award for delivering returns. Varallo says the judge considered Musk’s existing Tesla stake a substantial incentive: its value could rise by tens of billions if the company achieved the targets, even without the additional options.

Varallo compares Musk with founders who rely principally on the value of shares they already hold. He stresses that Tesla is a public company, with obligations that differ from those of a private company.

04

Possible next steps and the later appeal

Varallo discusses a potential replacement plan and a move out of Delaware. The state Supreme Court later reinstated the original award after reversing the rescission remedy.

Asked about the next steps, Varallo says it is initially the board’s responsibility to decide whether to develop another package. He expects neither the plaintiffs’ lawyers nor the judge to be involved if the board follows its duties and uses a reasonable process, but says a new package could draw scrutiny.

Chafkin asks whether Musk can move Tesla’s incorporation out of Delaware. Varallo says such a move would require a board decision and a shareholder vote, rather than a unilateral decision by Musk. He adds that he is not an expert in every state’s law.

An audience member asks whether the ruling changes Delaware’s tradition of judicial restraint. Varallo says Delaware courts have long examined fiduciaries’ decisions for both legal validity and fairness.

The later appeal changed the remedy discussed in this January 2024 interview. On December 19, 2025, the Delaware Supreme Court reversed the rescission of the 2018 plan, reinstated it and awarded the plaintiff nominal damages; the court took a narrower path on the remedy rather than resolving every disputed issue of liability.