Ray Comfort on Salvation, Repentance and Why Goodness Is Not Enough

Comfort says forgiveness requires repentance and faith in Jesus; Jewish host Shabbos Kestenbaum challenges why sincere repentance would not suffice.

RCRay Comfort게스트
채널
PragerU
게시일
2026년 11월 15일
영상
48:41
읽기
10분
원문
영어
YouTube에서 열기
스크롤하면 영상이 오른쪽 아래로 작아져 계속 재생됩니다. 자막은 읽기 언어를 따릅니다.
읽기 언어2개 언어로 읽을 수 있음
이 글은 아직 한국어 번역이 없어 영어 원문으로 표시합니다.
요약

30초 요약

Christian evangelist Ray Comfort argues that no one earns salvation by being comparatively good: everyone has sinned, and forgiveness comes through repentance and trust in Jesus. Orthodox Jewish host Shabbos Kestenbaum challenges why sincere repentance, prayer and repair would not be enough, and offers a different reading of Isaiah. Their exchange tests Comfort’s view against extreme wrongdoing, people who never hear of Jesus and the suffering of a world God created. Comfort says some questions remain beyond his understanding.

  1. 1Comfort says the measure is God’s law, not comparative goodnessWhen Kestenbaum asks whether a Jew who does not accept Jesus is going to hell, Comfort uses the commandments to explain why he believes everyone needs forgiveness.
  2. 2The speakers read Isaiah and the basis of forgiveness differentlyKestenbaum gives a Jewish reading of the suffering servant and asks why sincere repentance is insufficient. Comfort answers with his Christian understanding of sacrifice and Jesus.
  3. 3Comfort says faith must involve a changed heartHe rejects the idea that professing belief in Jesus gives someone permission to keep sinning without repentance.
  4. 4A hypothetical about grave evil tests the reach of mercyComfort says genuine repentance and faith could bring forgiveness in such a case, while declining to determine the fate of particular historical figures.
  5. 5Comfort leaves the reason God created a world with sin unansweredHe says he trusts God’s justice despite not knowing why God created people while knowing they would sin.
  6. 6Comfort is tentative about accountability for infantsHe offers a personal belief about becoming accountable for knowing wrongdoing, but says he is not certain how every case is judged.

핵심 정리

  1. Comfort distinguishes salvation through repentance and faith in Jesus from earning heaven by being comparatively good.
  2. Kestenbaum describes a Jewish understanding in which repentance includes prayer, changed conduct and seeking forgiveness from people harmed.
  3. Comfort says genuine repentance would make mercy possible even in a hypothetical involving extreme wrongdoing, while leaving actual judgment to God.
  4. Comfort says he cannot fully explain why God created people knowing they would sin, and is uncertain about some cases involving accountability.
전문

챕터별로 다듬은 전문 읽기

원본 자막만 보기
01

What makes a person good?

Comfort describes how he speaks with strangers and why he separates salvation from a person’s record of good deeds. Kestenbaum asks him to apply that standard to an actual life.

Shabbos Kestenbaum asks whether a good person can go to hell, and whether someone must believe in Jesus to enter heaven. His guest, Christian evangelist Ray Comfort, approaches the question by asking what counts as good when a person is measured against God's commandments.

Comfort says he is uncomfortable with labels such as televangelist and street preacher because they can suggest someone shouting at strangers. He prefers to begin a conversation calmly, ask people questions and listen. He often starts with trivia before moving to questions about the Ten Commandments.

His approach is to take a person's claim to goodness seriously and then ask about specific actions and thoughts. Kestenbaum describes himself as a good person, though far from perfect. Comfort says he also once regarded himself as good, but came to a different conclusion when he considered the commandments.

Asked whether he himself expects to go to heaven, Comfort says he does, but not because he has earned a place by being a good man. He believes he has sinned and depends on God's mercy through Jesus. That distinction between moral achievement and grace becomes central to the conversation.

Comfort says he has given students thousands of five-dollar gift cards, estimating the total at 35,000. He describes the gifts as an expression of love rather than an attempt to buy a hearing. Kestenbaum asks how such practical generosity relates to the faith Comfort shares with strangers.

02

How fear of death shaped Comfort’s conversion

Comfort recounts his New Zealand upbringing and his encounter with Christian teaching on sin. He explains the resulting faith through courtroom and parachute analogies.

Born in New Zealand in 1949, Comfort says his mother was Jewish and his father was not. His parents registered him as Methodist because of their fear that persecution of Jews could return. He describes growing up with material comfort and eventually establishing a business in leather and surf goods.

Around age 20, Comfort says, a sudden fear of death woke him at night. Material success could not settle the question of what would happen when he died. For months he wrestled with that fear before encountering Jesus' teaching in the Sermon on the Mount.

Comfort recalls being struck by Jesus' teaching that lust was adultery in the heart. He had not thought of himself as guilty of adultery, but the standard he heard there made him see his thoughts differently. In his account, this changed his understanding of sin and his need for forgiveness.

He explains his Christian belief with a courtroom analogy: a guilty person cannot erase a fine by claiming to be good, but another person can pay it. Comfort says Jesus' death and resurrection provide that payment, and that a person must repent and place trust in him rather than in their own record.

Comfort compares faith to putting on a parachute because one understands the danger of a fall. In his telling, faith is more than believing that the parachute exists; it means relying on it. His fear of death, he says, changed as he came to trust Jesus.

03

Faith, suffering and responsibility in this life

The speakers discuss beauty and suffering in the world. Kestenbaum describes the Jewish emphasis he places on human effort and ethical action.

Kestenbaum raises a question about valuing earthly life if a believer expects an eternal life afterward. Comfort says he appreciates the beauty of creation and the people in it, while also seeing pain, disease and death. He connects that suffering to a fallen world and says he hopes for God's restoration.

For Comfort, the promise of life after death does not make the present world meaningless. He says it makes him want others to hear the message he believes can save them. He also returns to the distinction between what people receive through grace and what they could earn through good conduct.

Kestenbaum describes a Jewish emphasis on human effort and ethical responsibility: faith is joined to what people do in the world. He invokes the teaching in Pirkei Avot that a person need not finish the work but is not free to abandon it. Comfort agrees that actions matter, while retaining his distinction about salvation.

04

The commandments behind Comfort’s answer

Asked directly about a Jew who does not accept Jesus, Comfort applies his reading of the commandments. He says everyone needs forgiveness and that salvation comes through Jesus.

Kestenbaum poses the question directly: as an observant Jew who does not accept Jesus as Lord and Savior, is he going to hell? He sees himself as imperfect but comparatively good and asks Comfort for a clear answer. Comfort says he wants first to explain the standard by which he believes everyone is judged.

Comfort compares the conversation to a doctor explaining a serious diagnosis before offering a cure. A patient who does not understand the disease will not understand why treatment matters, he says. His purpose in asking about the commandments is to show why, in his view, everyone needs forgiveness.

Comfort asks Kestenbaum about lying and stealing, then about taking God's name in vain. Rather than comparing one person with another, Comfort says the relevant measure is God's law. Kestenbaum answers the questions while noting that the religious framework Comfort is applying is not his own.

The questions move from actions to thoughts, including Jesus' teaching on lust. Comfort argues that a person who has broken God's commandments is guilty before a holy judge. Kestenbaum follows the logic of the exercise but distinguishes it from the way he understands Judaism.

Comfort says his conclusion applies to himself as well: he does not expect to be saved because his good deeds outweigh his sins. He argues that the way to forgiveness is repentance and trust in Jesus. Kestenbaum presses him on why a person who repents would also need that particular belief.

05

Why the speakers disagree about repentance

Kestenbaum and Comfort offer different readings of Isaiah and debate whether repentance and prayer suffice for forgiveness. Each explains the role of sacrifice in his own account.

The two disagree over Isaiah 53. Comfort reads the passage as pointing to Jesus, while Kestenbaum points to the surrounding text, including Isaiah 52, and says the Jewish reading he knows understands the suffering servant collectively as the Jewish people. He does not want the exchange to become a lengthy debate over the passage.

Kestenbaum instead asks about the Day of Atonement: if a Jewish person sincerely repents, asks God for forgiveness and tries to improve, why would that not be enough? His question turns the discussion from whether people sin to how forgiveness is understood in the two traditions.

Comfort asks what became of the blood sacrifices described in the Hebrew Bible. Kestenbaum says Jewish tradition understands prayer as standing in for Temple sacrifices after the Temple's destruction. Comfort responds from his Christian reading that sacrifice remains central to the way sin is dealt with.

Comfort offers another courtroom example. A bank robber cannot expect a judge to dismiss the case just because he apologizes and promises not to rob again, he argues. In his view, justice requires that the wrong be addressed; he believes Jesus' sacrifice meets that requirement permanently.

Kestenbaum explains repentance, prayer and charity as central responses to wrongdoing in the Jewish tradition he practices. When one person has harmed another, he says, asking God for forgiveness is not a substitute for seeking forgiveness from the person harmed. He presses the distinction between a genuine change of conduct and a mere apology.

Comfort turns to Psalm 51 and David's words about sinning against God. He argues that wrongdoing against another person is also, ultimately, an offense against God. Kestenbaum continues to ask why divine mercy and sincere repentance could not provide forgiveness without a belief in Jesus.

Kestenbaum observes that the Hebrew Bible portrays God forgiving people before Jesus. If God could forgive then, he asks, why is Jesus necessary now? Comfort answers from his Christian belief that Jesus is the promised Savior and that his identity and work are not confined to an ordinary human lifespan.

Their disagreement is not whether wrongdoing is real or whether people should turn away from it. It is over what forgiveness requires and how to read the biblical passages each brings to the question. Comfort maintains the necessity of Jesus; Kestenbaum presents repentance and repair within his Jewish framework.

06

A changed heart and the hardest cases

Comfort says genuine faith involves repentance and a changed desire to obey. A hypothetical involving extreme wrongdoing tests the reach of that mercy.

Kestenbaum tests another implication: could someone accept Jesus and then continue behaving badly, treating belief as a license to sin? Comfort says no. In his account, repentance and faith involve a changed heart and a desire to obey God, rather than an agreement to a statement followed by indifference to conduct.

Comfort says Christians still face temptation and do not become incapable of sin. What changes, he argues, is their relationship to it: they grieve over wrongdoing and want to turn away from it. Kestenbaum asks how that inward change relates to the judgment of people whose conduct has been especially destructive.

To test the limits of forgiveness, Kestenbaum asks about Osama bin Laden and then Hitler as hypothetical cases. Could someone responsible for enormous evil be forgiven by genuinely repenting and turning to Jesus at the end of life? He is probing whether salvation in Comfort's account is available irrespective of the scale of a person's crimes.

Comfort initially resists declaring what happened to any particular historical person, saying God knows the heart and judges the individual. He also asks Kestenbaum to consider his own need for forgiveness rather than using an extreme example to avoid that personal question.

When Kestenbaum keeps the question hypothetical and specifies sincere repentance and faith, Comfort accepts that God's offer of mercy would extend even to such a person. The condition is not a last-minute formula without a change of heart: Comfort emphasizes the sincerity of repentance and trust.

Kestenbaum returns to the tension this raises for him: an individual known for grave harm could, on that account, be forgiven, while someone he considers morally decent could be lost. Comfort answers by returning to his belief that all have sinned and that salvation rests on God's mercy rather than a ranking of people's lives.

07

Suffering, uncertainty and judgment

Comfort says he cannot fully explain why God created humanity knowing people would sin. He also addresses unforgivable sin, infants and people who never hear of Jesus, qualifying several answers.

Why would God create people knowing that many would not believe, Kestenbaum asks, and why allow so much suffering? Comfort says no person is without sin, but he does not claim to know why God created humanity knowing what would follow. He says he trusts God's justice despite not having an answer to every question.

Kestenbaum recognizes the experience of leaving some theological questions unresolved. The discussion turns to the limits of human understanding and the need, in each speaker's account, to live with questions that cannot be settled simply by producing a short answer.

Asked whether any sin cannot be forgiven, Comfort refers to Jesus' words about blasphemy against the Holy Spirit. He says the passage describes an unforgivable sin, while also acknowledging uncertainty about precisely how to define it. Kestenbaum asks what that means for people who have never heard the Christian message.

The host asks about infants who die and people who live far from any opportunity to hear about Jesus. Comfort says he personally believes there is a point at which a person becomes accountable for knowingly doing wrong, while qualifying that he is not certain how every such case is judged.

On those who have not heard, Comfort says he trusts God to judge justly and considers people's actions and circumstances relevant. He also argues that judgment is not necessarily identical in degree for every wrongdoer. His answer leaves the individual judgment to God rather than claiming knowledge of each person's fate.

08

Comfort’s story and parting appeal

Comfort describes the purpose of his memoir and offers a message to young people. Kestenbaum closes by thanking him for the exchange.

Comfort describes his memoir, Compelled: My Story, as an account of the change in his own life and the faith that has motivated his work. He says a person need not possess exceptional talent to speak to others about what they believe; his story is intended to show what an ordinary person can do.

Asked what he would say to young people, Comfort urges them to take God seriously, repent and trust Jesus. He frames the appeal around the brevity of life and his belief that forgiveness is available. Kestenbaum thanks him for answering difficult questions and says probing a belief is not the same as hostility toward its adherents.

같은 채널의 다른 글

23:31EN
PragerU· 2026년 11월 14일Caroline Downey on WNBA disputes and women’s sports categoriesShabbos Kestenbaum, Caroline Downey · PragerUDowney argues for sex-based sports categories and critiques the WNBA’s handling of Caitlin Clark and Sophie Cunningham.Political PhilosophySocial ActivismRelationships+1
13:03EN
PragerU· 2026년 11월 14일Iran holds to its uranium position as Nvidia changes CEOsCasey · PragerUIran rejects sending enriched uranium abroad; Nvidia appoints an interim CEO, and NASA plans a nuclear-powered lunar rover.
31:22EN
PragerU· 2026년 11월 14일Dennis Prager calls for “American values first”Dennis Prager, Marissa Streit · PragerUPrager argues that conservatism should center liberty, religious belief and a shared national identity, then answers questions about morality and the Hebrew Bible.Political PhilosophyReligion
1:19:07EN
PragerU· 2026년 11월 12일Victor Davis Hanson on Republicans, immigration and shared identityMarissa Streit, Victor Davis Hanson · PragerUHanson attributes the midterm defeat partly to messaging and Iran, and proposes immigration enforcement alongside a path to legal status for some long-term residents.Political PhilosophyGeopoliticsHistory+1
10:56EN
PragerU· 2026년 11월 12일Melissa Chen links her free-speech concerns to US-China rivalryMelissa ChenRaised in Singapore, Chen describes campus self-censorship and argues that China poses a major strategic threat to the US.Free SpeechGeopoliticsPolitical Philosophy
33:47EN
PragerU· 2026년 11월 11일Jill Simonian: West Point changed its mission, not its mottoJill Simonian · PragerU KidsThe PragerU Kids host argues schools should teach service and sacrifice alongside kindness, using West Point’s words as an example.EducationHistoryPolitical Philosophy