Musk on Twitter’s value, moderation and encrypted messages

In a 2023 interview, Elon Musk discusses his Twitter purchase, Community Notes and plans for private messages, alongside disputed political claims.

EMElon MuskInvité · Twitter
Chaîne
Fox News
Publié
18 avr. 2023
Vidéo
12:45
Lecture
3 min
Original
anglais
Ouvrir sur YouTube
En faisant défiler, la vidéo se réduit en bas à droite et continue. Les sous-titres suivent votre langue de lecture.
Langue de lectureDisponible en 2 langues
Cet article n’est pas encore disponible en français ; il s’affiche dans l’original en anglais.
RÉSUMÉ

En 30 secondes

In April 2023, Elon Musk told Tucker Carlson he viewed his $44 billion Twitter purchase as an investment in free expression despite a lower subsequent valuation. He discussed Community Notes and plans for optional encrypted direct messages. Musk also alleged broad government access to private messages, but the excerpt offers no evidence establishing its scope. His political interpretations and encryption timeline are presented as claims and plans from the interview.

  1. 1Musk frames a costly acquisition as a free-speech projectHe says Twitter was valued at less than half the $44 billion purchase price, but describes the platform as important to democracy.
  2. 2Community Notes is his example of user-added contextMusk describes a system in which participants add context to posts and work toward useful corrections.
  3. 3A claim of government access is not substantiated in the excerptMusk alleges agencies could access private messages; the interview offers no evidence of the scope.
  4. 4Encrypted direct messages were a future plan in April 2023Musk predicts an optional feature, intending that Twitter itself would be unable to read protected messages.
  5. 5The election conversation contains disputed interpretationsMusk discusses Zuckerberg’s donations and political fairness. The interview does not establish a partisan intent behind the grants.

À retenir

  1. Musk said Twitter’s valuation had fallen sharply after his $44 billion purchase, but he considered an open public forum important to democracy.
  2. He described Community Notes as a way for users to add context and correct posts.
  3. He alleged extensive government access to private messages; the excerpt does not substantiate the scope of that allegation.
  4. In April 2023, Musk predicted optional encrypted messages would arrive soon; this is a historical forecast.
  5. The interview’s partisan interpretation of election donations is not established by the discussion.
TEXTE INTÉGRAL

Lire le texte remanié, chapitre par chapitre

Transcription seule
01

The price of Twitter and the case for an open forum

Musk discusses the acquisition, its valuation and Community Notes.

Tucker Carlson introduces his interview with Elon Musk about buying Twitter. Carlson characterizes the platform before the purchase as an instrument of intelligence agencies; the interview excerpt does not establish that claim.

Musk says he paid $44 billion for Twitter and that a subsequent internal valuation put it at less than half that amount. He describes the purchase as a costly effort to protect free speech and argues that a trusted public forum matters to democracy.

Musk points to Community Notes, which lets users add context to posts, as part of his approach. He says the aim is for competing viewpoints to converge on helpful corrections, although he does not claim that every note is perfect.

Carlson asks whether powerful people resent an open platform. Musk says criticism is inevitable and argues that the public ultimately decides whether to use the service.

02

Verification, prior management and financing

The conversation turns to the New York Times account, automated activity and the acquisition.

Musk discusses the removal of a verification badge from the New York Times account and criticizes the volume of its posts. He suggests the outlet might better serve readers by selecting a smaller number of its best stories.

The conversation returns to Twitter’s former management, automated accounts and government influence. Musk says he distrusted what he found and describes financing the acquisition with support from other investors and debt.

03

Government access claims and encryption plans

Musk alleges broad access to user information and describes a planned encrypted messaging option.

Musk alleges that various government agencies had full access to Twitter user activity, including private direct messages, and says the extent surprised him. The excerpt supplies no evidence establishing the scope of that alleged access; the assertion should not be treated as proof that agencies could read all private messages.

Musk says he wants optional encryption for direct messages so that even Twitter cannot read their contents, and predicts it may arrive that month or the next. This was a plan expressed in April 2023, not a description of the feature’s present availability or security.

Carlson asks about government influence and Musk’s businesses that have government contracts. Musk says constitutional protection of speech matters and presents the platform’s independence as important.

04

Election fairness and political views

Musk discusses election-related donations, Trump and his own political preferences.

Asked about elections, Musk says Twitter should be fair to different political viewpoints. Carlson and Musk then discuss Mark Zuckerberg’s election-related donations; Musk suggests they benefited Democrats, but the interview does not establish partisan intent.

For context, the [Center for Tech and Civic Life](https://www.techandciviclife.org/2020covidsupport/) reports distributing nearly $350 million to local election departments in its 2020 COVID-19 response program and says grants were awarded without partisan considerations. Its [announcement](https://www.techandciviclife.org/100m/) identifies $350 million in contributions from Zuckerberg and Priscilla Chan for that program.

Asked whether Donald Trump will return to Twitter, Musk says that is Trump’s decision. He says he voted for Joe Biden in 2020 and describes his preference for a politically moderate approach. The excerpt ends during the exchange.

Sur la même chaîne