Trump and Musk’s 2024 conversation: borders, spending and energy

In a two-hour campaign discussion, Trump and Musk argue for border enforcement, spending cuts and a different approach to energy.

DTDonald TrumpInvité
Chaîne
Donald J Trump
Publié
13 août 2024
Vidéo
2:05:58
Lecture
8 min
Original
anglais
Ouvrir sur YouTube
En faisant défiler, la vidéo se réduit en bas à droite et continue. Les sous-titres suivent votre langue de lecture.
Langue de lectureDisponible en 2 langues
Cet article n’est pas encore disponible en français ; il s’affiche dans l’original en anglais.
RÉSUMÉ

En 30 secondes

In August 2024, Elon Musk endorsed Donald Trump and offered to help a proposed government efficiency commission. Their wide-ranging conversation covered the Butler assassination attempt, immigration, inflation, foreign policy and energy. Trump alleged that other countries were sending prisoners to the U.S., a claim not established in the conversation. Musk favored a gradual shift to sustainable energy while arguing against vilifying oil and gas workers; both framed their remarks around the approaching election.

  1. 1Trump recalls the Butler shootingHe describes turning toward an immigration chart and being struck in the ear; Musk says his reaction helped motivate the endorsement.
  2. 2Trump proposed deportations and alleged a prison schemeHe claimed foreign countries were sending prisoners to the U.S.; the conversation did not establish the broad allegation.
  3. 3Musk offered to help review federal spendingHe proposed a government efficiency commission, and Trump praised the idea of cutting costs.
  4. 4Musk advocated a gradual energy transitionHe said society currently relies on oil and gas but should move over time toward sustainable energy.
  5. 5The pair wanted faster access to experimental treatmentsTrump discussed Right to Try, while Musk argued for recognizing medicines approved elsewhere. Eligibility does not guarantee access or effectiveness.
  6. 6Musk appealed to moderate votersHe described his own political history as moderate or center-left and urged listeners to support Trump.

À retenir

  1. Musk offered to help review government spending and endorsed Trump in the 2024 election.
  2. Trump promised large-scale deportations and alleged foreign governments were sending prisoners, without establishing the broad allegation.
  3. Musk favored a gradual sustainable-energy transition while acknowledging present reliance on oil and gas.
  4. Both argued for fewer regulations; Trump proposed shifting federal education responsibilities to states.
TEXTE INTÉGRAL

Lire le texte remanié, chapitre par chapitre

Transcription seule
01

The Butler shooting and its aftermath

Trump recounts the attack, praises responders and discusses security failures with Musk.

Elon Musk apologizes for a delayed start, attributing it to a denial-of-service attack, and introduces the exchange as a conversation intended for open-minded voters. Donald Trump congratulates him on the audience.

Musk asks about the July 2024 assassination attempt in Butler, Pennsylvania, and says Trump’s raised fist afterward was part of why he endorsed him. Trump recalls being hit in the ear while turning toward an immigration chart.

Trump remembers firefighter Corey Comperatore, who was killed, and says money was raised for his family and two people who were wounded. He praises the medical care the injured received.

He credits a Secret Service countersniper with stopping the shooter. Musk asks how a gunman could reach a nearby roof; Trump says the building should have been covered and describes a local officer’s encounter with the shooter.

Trump says the crowd did not stampede and praises agents who covered him. He and Musk discuss a breakdown in coordination and speculate about the timing of the shots; Trump says he wanted to stand and show the crowd he was alive.

Trump says turning toward an immigration chart may have saved his life and describes the timing as a miracle. He says he plans to return to Butler in October.

02

Immigration, enforcement and disputed claims

Both call for tighter border control. Trump proposes deportations and makes broad allegations about foreign prisoners that the conversation does not establish.

The conversation turns to immigration. Trump praises his earlier border policies and criticizes the Biden administration and Vice President Kamala Harris. He alleges that other countries are sending prisoners and people from institutions to the United States.

Musk says a secure border and an efficient legal immigration process are both important. He says he believes most unauthorized immigrants are hardworking, while arguing that an uncontrolled process can also admit people who commit crimes.

Trump repeats claims that countries are emptying prisons into the United States and attributes falling crime abroad to that alleged practice. He says he would carry out large-scale deportations. These broad claims and figures are not established by the conversation.

Musk recalls visiting Eagle Pass, Texas, and seeing people cross. Both argue that border conditions are unsustainable; Trump criticizes Harris’s record and predicts much larger migration under a Democratic administration.

03

Foreign leaders, war and nuclear risk

Trump argues that his approach deterred adversaries. Both describe nuclear escalation as a serious concern.

Trump criticizes the process by which Joe Biden withdrew from the presidential race and Harris became the Democratic candidate. He argues that conflicts and inflation would have been avoided under his leadership; Musk says adversaries must perceive the U.S. president as strong.

Trump describes his relationship with Vladimir Putin and disputes criticism of his approach to Russia. He contrasts his treatment of Nord Stream 2 with Biden’s cancellation of the Keystone XL oil pipeline.

He discusses China, North Korea and Iran, saying he believes his relationships and threats of sanctions deterred aggression. Musk agrees that international leaders respond to strength. These are their assessments of what might have happened under different leadership.

Trump recalls trading threats with North Korea’s Kim Jong Un before their meetings in Singapore and Vietnam. He says the relationship reduced the danger of war and describes crossing into North Korea.

Trump argues that nuclear war is a greater immediate concern than global warming and says Russia’s invasion of Ukraine would not have happened if he had remained president. Musk agrees that nuclear escalation is a grave risk.

04

Inflation, spending and the role of government

Musk proposes a spending review commission, and Trump discusses energy costs, education and deregulation. Inflation has multiple causes.

Trump proposes a U.S. missile-defense shield and says voters are especially concerned about grocery prices. He blames the administration for inflation and says households have had to use savings or borrow to cover expenses.

Musk argues that government overspending drives inflation and proposes a commission to review spending. Trump emphasizes energy costs and promises more oil and gas production. The [Congressional Budget Office](https://www.cbo.gov/publication/60480) attributes the 2021–22 inflation surge to several factors, including supply disruptions, demand and energy and food costs.

Musk asks whether a government efficiency commission could make spending more sensible. Trump recounts negotiating the cost of replacement Air Force One aircraft and says procurement offers many opportunities for savings.

Musk offers to help such a commission. Trump praises his willingness to cut costs; both point to Argentina’s Javier Milei and spending reductions as an example, while making their own assessments of the results.

Trump proposes closing the federal Education Department and moving responsibilities to states, arguing that state competition would improve schools and lower costs. Musk says people could move to states with better policies.

They criticize governance in California and Illinois and discuss businesses and residents moving between states. Musk argues states should not assume a federal bailout; Trump says lenders and residents should not bear the consequences of poor management.

Returning to inflation, Musk says it erodes savings and argues for lower spending and fewer unnecessary rules. Trump describes the strain of grocery costs and says his earlier administration reduced regulations.

Trump says the pandemic interrupted his economic plans, praises his administration’s response and criticizes later spending. He argues that additional oil and gas production would help the economy.

05

Oil, climate and nuclear power

Musk argues for a gradual sustainable-energy transition. The two discuss climate and nuclear power with differing emphases.

Musk says society currently depends on oil and gas and that workers in those industries should not be vilified. He favors a gradual transition to sustainable energy, saying fossil fuels are finite and rising carbon dioxide poses risks.

He estimates atmospheric carbon dioxide is rising by a few parts per million per year and argues that the transition need not impose immediate hardship. Trump says fossil fuel supplies could last much longer and discusses opening an Alaska oil area to development.

Musk says he expects solar power and batteries to supply much of the world’s energy over time and presents Tesla’s electric cars as part of that shift. Trump suggests putting solar panels on vehicle surfaces.

Trump again prioritizes nuclear weapons over climate change. Earlier he minimized sea-level rise; [NOAA’s 2024 materials](https://www.noaa.gov/sites/default/files/2024-09/HurricaneWebinarSlides.pdf) report global sea level had risen about seven to eight inches since 1900. Musk distinguishes nuclear war from nuclear electricity and argues that power generation deserves reconsideration.

Trump raises fears about long-lasting contamination after accidents in Japan and the former Soviet Union. Musk argues that nuclear power is safer than commonly believed and recalls visiting Japan after Fukushima. Their brief exchange does not establish the safety of every affected location.

06

The campaign, courts and European allies

They criticize prosecutions and Harris’s record, discuss NATO and call for a Trump victory.

The pair criticize criminal cases against Trump as politically motivated. Trump says the Florida case was dismissed and argues prosecutions set a dangerous precedent; these are his characterizations of the cases.

Trump and Musk criticize Harris’s record on crime, immigration and energy, arguing that her campaign presents her as more moderate than her earlier positions. Musk says voters should examine her record; both state their support for Trump in the 2024 race.

Musk mentions a European Commission letter concerning illegal content and describes it as an attempt to impose censorship. Trump responds with criticism of European trade practices and says Europe should bear more of the cost of its defense and support for Ukraine.

Trump says he pushed NATO allies to increase defense spending; Musk argues that the United States contributes disproportionately. Trump also recalls his dealings with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and criticizes his own impeachment.

Musk says he regards Trump as a free-speech advocate and praises the opportunity for an extended conversation. Both contrast this format with their descriptions of Biden and Harris.

07

Infrastructure, medicine and closing arguments

They imagine ambitious projects, discuss access to experimental treatments and return to crime and election priorities.

Musk says Americans should be inspired by ambitious projects such as a Moon base, missions to Mars and faster transport between cities. He points to the Las Vegas tunnel project and proposes more tunnels; Trump says he admires high-speed trains and wants better transport.

Musk argues that rules accumulate and slow new technologies. He proposes faster drug approvals; Trump says his administration accelerated some reviews and discusses the federal Right to Try law for eligible patients with life-threatening conditions.

Trump says Right to Try helped patients who had exhausted options. Musk suggests recognizing medicines approved in Europe when patients understand the risks. The [FDA describes Right to Try](https://www.fda.gov/media/133864/download) as a pathway for eligible patients to request certain investigational drugs, rather than a guarantee of access or effectiveness.

Trump asks voters whether they were better off during his presidency, returning to inflation and crime. Musk recounts assaults described to him by his mother and says prosecutors should focus on violent offenders.

Both again describe the cases against Trump as an abuse of the legal system. Trump warns that prosecuting political opponents could create a precedent and says the cases drive business away from New York.

Musk renews his endorsement, saying he wants an optimistic future and believes Trump can provide it. Trump thanks him and says the election will determine whether the country can recover.

Musk says he previously supported Barack Obama and considers himself historically moderate or center-left. He describes the election as a turning point and urges other moderates to support Trump.

The two return to immigration, crime, spending and the justice system. Trump again alleges foreign governments are sending criminals; Musk says he wants safe cities, secure borders and effective government.

Trump predicts crime will rise and suggests a future meeting in Venezuela would be safer. The [FBI’s preliminary first-quarter 2024 comparison](https://www.fbi.gov/news/press-releases/fbi-releases-2024-quarterly-crime-report-and-use-of-force-data-update) showed reported violent crime falling among participating agencies compared with the same period in 2023; that comparison is limited to agencies submitting comparable data.

They discuss an assault on New York police officers and criticize bail and prosecution decisions. Trump says police need support and repeats his proposal to deport criminal noncitizens; the individual case does not establish their wider claims about all prosecutions.

Trump recounts using the threat of withholding foreign aid to secure the return of deportees. Musk says protecting society requires considering victims as well as offenders and supports incarceration of repeat violent offenders.

Trump says he entered politics despite a comfortable private life because he believed the country needed him. Musk summarizes his priorities as safe cities, secure borders, prudent spending, deregulation and ambitious projects, while reiterating support for a gradual energy transition.

Trump promises incentives for companies to build and hire in the United States and says he has learned from his first term. Both call the November 2024 election consequential, thank each other and end the conversation.