Tesla’s 2010 bet on Model S: rising spending before mass production

On the third-quarter call, Musk and CFO Deepak Ahuja laid out the sedan’s milestones, finances and automaker partnerships.

EMElon MuskPonente · TeslaDADeepak AhujaPonente · Tesla
Canal
Elon Musk best videos
Publicado
6 dic 2015
Vídeo
1:10:16
Lectura
7 min
Original
inglés
Abrir en YouTube
Al desplazarte, el vídeo se reduce a la esquina inferior derecha y sigue reproduciéndose. Los subtítulos siguen tu idioma de lectura.
Idioma de lecturaDisponible en 2 idiomas
Este artículo aún no está en español, así que se muestra el original en inglés.
RESUMEN

En 30 segundos

In the third quarter of 2010, Tesla reported $31.2 million in revenue and a $34.9 million GAAP net loss as it invested in Model S. Elon Musk targeted first deliveries in mid-2012 and around 20,000 cars in 2013, while warning that profitability would take time. CFO Deepak Ahuja explained the DOE loan and a $60 million Toyota RAV4 development agreement; Musk also outlined fast-charging plans and identified final integration and safety testing as schedule risks.

  1. 1Model S remained targeted for mid-2012 deliveriesMusk described the Fremont factory purchase, prototype progress and a planned ramp to roughly 20,000 vehicles in 2013.
  2. 2Automaker partnerships funded powertrain developmentTesla supplied Daimler and signed an approximately $60 million agreement to develop the Toyota RAV4 electric powertrain.
  3. 3Revenue rose sequentially while Tesla recorded a lossAhuja reported $31.2 million in quarterly revenue and a $34.9 million GAAP net loss as investment increased.
  4. 4DOE financing reimbursed eligible development costsTesla had drawn $56.6 million of the $465 million loan facility by September 30, according to Ahuja.
  5. 5Musk outlined an 80-kW fast-charging planHe expected strategically placed direct-current chargers and estimated around 45 minutes for a partial charge of the planned pack.
  6. 6Final safety and integration work could affect timingMusk identified crash testing and the details of integrating vehicle systems as risks to the Model S schedule.

Conclusiones

  1. Tesla’s 2010 plan prioritized Model S development and a production ramp over near-term profits.
  2. Third-quarter revenue was $31.2 million and GAAP net loss was $34.9 million.
  3. The Toyota RAV4 development contract was separate from potential production powertrain sales.
  4. Musk planned fast chargers along major routes and identified final safety and systems integration as timing risks.
  5. Ahuja cautioned that development-services margins were influenced by the timing of revenue and expenses.
TEXTO COMPLETO

Lee el texto editado por capítulos

Solo la transcripción
01

Model S milestones and partnerships

Musk reviews Roadster deliveries, Model S plans, the Fremont factory and partnerships with Daimler, Toyota and Panasonic.

Elon Musk says Tesla aims to report progress regularly and describes the third quarter of 2010 as solid across Roadster, Model S and powertrain work.

Tesla completed the Fremont factory purchase, advanced the Model S prototype and maintained a target of customer deliveries in mid-2012. Musk also cites the Toyota RAV4 agreement, Daimler deliveries and a $30 million Panasonic investment.

Musk emphasizes recruiting, calling a company the combined result of its people. He says Tesla has been attracting strong applicants at all levels.

Tesla delivered 151 Roadsters in the quarter, up 7% from the previous quarter, and new orders rose over 15%. Musk says these were new customers rather than merely an old backlog.

He describes a round-the-world Roadster trip charged from local electricity grids and discusses store openings in Paris, Tokyo and other cities. The company also wants to improve the purchase and service experience under retail executive George Blankenship.

Model S is scheduled for a gradual production ramp from mid-2012, with a goal of around 20,000 vehicles in 2013. Musk says Tesla bought used manufacturing equipment cheaply for the former NUMMI plant.

The Fremont facility has permits for substantially greater eventual capacity, though Musk calls half a million vehicles per year a long-term aspiration. Its layout is intended to support Model S derivatives and a later mass-market vehicle.

The Model S powertrain is undergoing road and laboratory tests. Musk expects a 45-minute fast-charge capability and says the first complete alpha prototype should be driving by year-end.

Tesla expects to complete most supplier decisions by the end of the quarter. It has more than 3,000 Model S reservations, each requiring at least $5,000, and hopes to sell out the first year of production before manufacturing begins.

Tesla delivered battery packs and chargers for Daimler’s electric Smart and completed development work for the electric Mercedes A-Class. Its approximately $60 million Toyota agreement covers development of a complete RAV4 electric powertrain.

Musk says Panasonic’s investment grew out of a long relationship. Tesla and Panasonic have refined an automotive cell in the familiar 18650 cylindrical format, and their agreement is not exclusive.

Musk says near-term quarterly profitability is not the priority while Tesla invests roughly half a billion dollars over the coming quarters to scale from hundreds of Roadsters to planned Model S production.

He expects an alpha prototype to appear in an exploded display at the Detroit auto show, illustrating Tesla’s vehicle engineering as well as its powertrain and design work.

02

Quarterly results and financing

Ahuja explains revenue, margins, losses, cash, the DOE loan and guidance.

Chief financial officer Deepak Ahuja says third-quarter revenue was $31.2 million, up 10% from the prior quarter. He separates automotive sales from development services and explains that non-GAAP figures supplement, rather than replace, GAAP results.

Roadster revenue fell sequentially to $18.2 million despite higher deliveries, partly because a larger share of U.S. cars was leased and revenue would be recognized over time. Powertrain component revenue rose to $5.1 million.

Development services revenue rose to $7.9 million, driven by Daimler milestones and recognition of deferred revenue; Tesla also began recognizing revenue from early Toyota prototypes.

Total gross margin was 30%, up from 22%, helped by the mix of development services. Ahuja cautions that the 68% development-services margin is affected by the timing of revenue and expenses and should not be extrapolated.

Automotive gross margin was about 17%, including warranty adjustments for a voluntary Roadster auxiliary-cable recall. Ahuja says the company had reserved for the worldwide repair.

GAAP research and development expense was $26.7 million as Model S engineering and supplier work expanded. Tesla added production and manufacturing staff and expects development spending to rise unevenly.

A non-cash gain from changes in warrant fair value affected the quarter. GAAP net loss was $34.9 million, or $0.38 per share; non-GAAP loss was $34.2 million.

Ahuja reports $96.6 million in unrestricted cash at quarter-end and explains the separate Department of Energy dedicated account. He says the account initially funds part of eligible costs and is subsequently reimbursed under the loan arrangement.

He describes eligible costs awaiting reimbursement and says operating activities used $46 million in cash during the quarter. Roughly half of that operating use relates to expenses reimbursable under the loan, he says.

Inventory increased as Tesla planned to build Roadsters faster than its sales forecast before Lotus stopped supplying gliders at the end of 2011. The aim was to support Roadster sales in 2012.

Ahuja discusses capital spending on the Fremont facility and says Tesla had drawn $56.6 million of the $465 million DOE loan by September 30. The loan is intended to reimburse eligible Model S and powertrain development and facilities costs.

The Toyota RAV4 development agreement is expected to generate about $60 million over roughly six quarters once specifications are finalized. Production powertrain sales would require a separate agreement.

Panasonic’s $30 million investment made it a shareholder; Ahuja says the companies are jointly developing a customized cell without an exclusive supply agreement. Tesla maintains 2010 revenue guidance of $110 million to $115 million.

03

Questions on charging, competition and execution

Analysts ask about Toyota volumes, fast charging, powertrain opportunities and risks to the Model S schedule.

In questions, Musk says Toyota plans to start the electric RAV4 with a test fleet of a few thousand vehicles, then assess customer interest and reliability before deciding on larger volumes.

He describes a planned approximately 80-kW direct-current fast charger that bypasses the car’s onboard charger. Tesla expects a few strategic locations along major routes when Model S production begins.

For a roughly 70-kWh pack, Musk estimates around 45 minutes to charge from approximately 5–10% to 85–90%, rather than from completely empty to full.

Asked about competition, Musk says he sees no major change known to Tesla and views the Toyota and Panasonic relationships as support for its technology, while acknowledging there may be developments he does not know.

He declines to forecast powertrain sales because they depend heavily on decisions by a small number of automaker executives. Tesla is in other discussions, but he says it has also declined projects to protect its capacity and Model S schedule.

Ahuja declines to give a specific year-end cash forecast and notes that DOE reimbursement timing creates lags. He says Model S capital spending remains within broad plans and contingencies.

Musk says savings on used equipment are partly offset by additional product features, including a panoramic roof. He describes the company’s focus on the car’s appearance as well as its functionality.

Musk identifies final systems integration, crash testing and refining safety systems as potential schedule risks. A car may look finished before the detailed work needed for production is complete, he says.

The Toyota RAV4 and Model S powertrains share core elements, Musk says, although integrating each into its vehicle differs. Tesla retains its core intellectual property while Toyota owns vehicle-specific integration work.

He says the planned RAV4 battery pack is about 40 kWh, smaller than Model S. Tesla is not releasing detailed same-store Roadster sales, partly because customers can buy through several channels and across borders.

04

Toyota assembly, leases and Panasonic

The discussion covers revenue recognition, potential RAV4 assembly, Roadster leases and Tesla’s battery relationship.

Ahuja clarifies that the $60 million Toyota development contract was signed in October, so it contributed no third-quarter revenue; revenue from earlier RAV4 prototypes was recorded as development services.

Asked about possible RAV4 assembly in Fremont, Musk says the decision belongs to Toyota. He sees value in early assembly near the powertrain team so that any problems can be corrected quickly.

Musk says Model S powertrain tests have produced no major surprises so far. Tesla expects improvements in cost, performance and packaging, with more cargo space from a compact layout.

Ahuja says leases represented about 30% of U.S. Roadster deliveries and about 20% globally in the quarter. He explains that Tesla itself financed the leased vehicles.

On Panasonic, Musk traces the cell relationship through Sanyo and Panasonic and says the investment did not impose an obligation to buy Panasonic cells. He suggests the stake reflects a desire for a closer strategic relationship.

Musk says Daimler and Toyota had not discussed a three-way battery arrangement directly with Tesla. He declines to speak for the automakers about any conversations they may have had.

On a potential Fremont RAV4 program, he reiterates that Tesla must stay focused on launching Model S well and on time. Taking on too much too early, he says, can leave a fast-growing company doing several things poorly.

Ahuja says slightly more than half of quarterly Roadster deliveries were in the United States, with most of the remainder in Europe. Management closes by inviting listeners to see the Model S display in Detroit.

Más de este canal

13:40EN
Elon Musk best videos· 11 dic 2015Elon Musk’s 2014 plan for affordable Teslas and a city on MarsInvitado: Elon MuskMusk said costly early cars would fund a cheaper Tesla, while Mars settlement would require a dramatic fall in travel costs.TeslaElectric VehiclesSpaceX+1
28:23EN
Elon Musk best videos· 8 dic 2015Elon Musk in 2011: Reusable Rockets, NASA and SpaceX’s First Crew PlansInvitado: Elon MuskDuring a visit to SpaceX’s Hawthorne factory, Musk discusses the cost of spaceflight, Dragon’s design and his long-term ambition for Mars.SpaceXInfraestructura y despliegueEntrepreneurship+1
23:36EN
Elon Musk best videos· 6 dic 2015Musk’s 2010 plan for Model S, an SUV and a cheaper TeslaInvitado: Elon MuskBefore Model S production, Musk outlined development milestones, charging choices and the next vehicles on Tesla’s roadmap.TeslaElectric VehiclesProduct Strategy
24:50EN
Elon Musk best videos· 4 dic 2015Elon Musk on Leaving PayPal and Preparing SpaceX’s Fourth LaunchInvitado: Elon MuskBefore Falcon 1’s fourth flight, Musk explains the PayPal dispute, Tesla’s Roadster decisions and SpaceX’s early launch failures.SpaceXTeslaEntrepreneurship+2
31:15EN
Elon Musk best videos· 27 nov 2015Elon Musk in 2010: Tesla’s Early Strategy, Funding and Entrepreneurial AdviceInvitado: Elon Musk · Presenta: Bambi FranciscoIn a Vator interview, Musk explains the Roadster-to-Model S strategy, early financing and the questions he believes founders should ask themselves.TeslaSpaceXElectric Vehicles+2
46:34EN
Elon Musk best videos· 26 nov 2015Musk in 2003: From PayPal’s email payments to a small rocketAt Stanford, Musk explained how user behavior redirected PayPal and why SpaceX began with satellite launches.EntrepreneurshipCompany BuildingHistory+1