Walter Isaacson on Musk’s appeal and a campus citation dispute

The biographer considers Musk’s polarizing appeal, debates attribution at Harvard and briefly discusses media consolidation.

WIWalter IsaacsonGuest
Channel
CNBC Television
Published
Dec 21, 2023
Video
8:22
Read
3 min
Original
English
Open on YouTube
Scroll to read and the video shrinks to the bottom-right corner. Captions follow your reading language.
Reading languageAvailable in 2 languages
You're reading the original English.
SUMMARY

In 30 seconds

Walter Isaacson says Elon Musk’s influence makes him worth understanding even when his actions divide opinion. In a December 2023 CNBC discussion, the biographer also debates Harvard President Claudine Gay’s citation controversy: he urges clearer attribution while arguing the institution should assess the broader leadership question. The hosts challenge his assessment. Gay stepped down as president in January 2024; the panel also briefly considers reported media merger talks.

  1. 1Isaacson sees Musk as influential and polarizingAfter following Musk for his biography, he says that even people who dislike his actions need to understand the companies and decisions affecting them.
  2. 2The panel disputes the significance of Harvard citation allegationsIsaacson argues for taking time to assess the university’s leadership; the hosts ask whether students would be treated differently.
  3. 3Isaacson recommends generous, visible attributionHe recalls telling writers at Time to credit sources near the ideas used, instead of burying acknowledgment.
  4. 4Media merger scrutiny depends on market definitionIsaacson points to the difficulty of defining a media content market and the blocked Penguin Random House–Simon & Schuster deal.

Takeaways

  1. Isaacson says Musk can engage and infuriate people at the same time, while affecting industries across daily life.
  2. He recommends clearly crediting sources near the ideas or language they contributed.
  3. The hosts and Isaacson disagree over the seriousness of the Harvard citation allegations and the university’s response.
  4. Isaacson says media antitrust analysis depends in part on how the market is defined.
FULL TEXT

Read the edited text by chapter

Transcript only
01

Why Musk divides opinion

The hosts discuss a poll on billionaires. Isaacson reflects on Musk’s appeal and the influence of X.

The Squawk Box hosts introduce Walter Isaacson, author of a biography of Elon Musk, and discuss a CNBC poll comparing public views of wealthy business figures. They note that Musk’s net rating was around zero in the poll while other technology leaders scored lower.

Isaacson says Musk has long divided opinion. After following him for two and a half years, he still finds himself wondering whether Musk’s actions will cause a venture to fail. He says Musk’s influence across several industries makes him a person worth understanding, even for people who find him infuriating.

The hosts discuss criticism of social media and the poll’s low ratings for Mark Zuckerberg and Jeff Bezos. Isaacson says he is unsure how much to trust all polling results; the panel offers different guesses about what shapes the public’s reaction.

Isaacson argues that X had attracted engagement around the Israel–Gaza war, antisemitism and campus controversies, while some brand advertisers had pulled back. He suggests direct-response advertising might become more important. One host questions the quality of products bought through such ads.

02

Harvard, citation and institutional leadership

Isaacson and the hosts disagree about the significance of allegations involving Claudine Gay. They debate attribution and standards for leaders and students.

The conversation turns to plagiarism allegations involving Harvard President Claudine Gay. Isaacson argues that the university should take time to assess the situation and says he does not regard the citation problems as the most important question facing its leadership.

The hosts press Isaacson on how a student would be treated for comparable conduct. He says writers should name the source of an idea clearly and use appropriate citations and quotation marks, while maintaining that the more important issue is whether a leader can run a complex institution.

Isaacson recalls telling writers at Time to err on the side of generous attribution, placing the source near the idea rather than hiding it in acknowledgments. The hosts disagree over how seriously to treat the allegations and the wider campus controversy.

One host says the issue extends beyond citation to university leaders’ responses to antisemitism. Isaacson clarifies that his call to pause concerned citation practices. The panel briefly argues about faculty hiring, tenure and political views.

03

Media consolidation and what happened later

Isaacson briefly discusses reported merger talks and the difficulty of antitrust analysis. Harvard announced Gay’s resignation after the interview.

With little time left, Isaacson turns to reported talks involving Warner Bros. Discovery and Paramount. He says assessing antitrust questions is difficult because defining the relevant market for media content is complicated, and recalls the blocked Penguin Random House–Simon & Schuster acquisition. The conversation aired on December 21, 2023. Harvard announced on January 2, 2024 that Gay had stepped down as president; the interview participants did not know that outcome at the time.

More from this channel