In 30 seconds
A faster production line exposed paint-drying problems, Elon Musk tells manufacturing consultant Sandy Munro. They discuss how large castings can replace many joins and how a structural battery pack could both store energy and stiffen a car. Musk also warns that a driver-assistance system that works most of the time can make drivers complacent before it handles unusual cases.
- 1Faster production exposed a paint-drying problemMusk says a shorter drying interval contributed to quality issues during the ramp.
- 2Large castings can replace joins and sealantMusk says the Model Y rear casting also reduced the size of the body shop.
- 3A structural battery pack can do two jobsMusk describes cells storing energy while helping transfer forces between layers.
- 4The casting alloy was designed to avoid distortionMusk says a subsequent heat-treatment step could warp large parts.
- 5A mostly capable driving system can invite complacencyMusk says the transition is dangerous if drivers relax before unusual cases are handled.
Takeaways
- Production changes can uncover quality problems that prototypes do not show.
- Fewer body parts can mean fewer joints, seals and opportunities for variation.
- A structural battery pack is intended to serve both energy and structural functions.
- Materials must account for distortion and different rates of thermal expansion.
- Supervised driving still requires an attentive driver.
Read the edited text by chapter
Production quality changes during a ramp
Musk and Munro discuss panel gaps, paint and seat design.
Manufacturing consultant Sandy Munro meets Elon Musk at SpaceX’s Boca Chica site. Munro recalls criticizing uneven panel gaps on a Model 3; Musk says those criticisms were accurate.
Munro describes seeing cars built close together in time with noticeably different quality. Musk says a fast production ramp makes it especially hard to get every detail right.
Musk says Tesla improved gaps and paint quality toward the end of 2020. As an example, he says increasing line speed had shortened paint-drying time and exposed problems the team then had to correct.
He distinguishes a prototype from a dependable, affordable product made in volume. Munro says the improvement he observed led him to recommend the Model Y to people asking about electric cars.
After a long road trip, Munro praises the seats. Musk says the design goal was to distribute pressure rather than create concentrated points that become uncomfortable over time.
Musk says the seats went through many iterations and compares them with early Model S seats he found uncomfortable. The aim was to retain comfort over long periods.
Munro argues that components customers touch are important to a manufacturer’s own expertise. Musk says an in-house team can iterate and describes trying to reproduce the feel of a hand-built design in an affordable production seat.
Driver assistance and its limits
They discuss confusing road markings, beta testing and the difficulty of measuring software by line count.
Munro raises inconsistent road markings and describes a confusing roadworks situation while using driver assistance. He asks whether road authorities should make markings more consistent.
Musk says clear markings would help, but argues that a future self-driving system must prioritize avoiding a collision even when markings are wrong or a situation is unusual.
Munro describes a supervised beta drive that impressed him and predicts large safety benefits. Musk credits Tesla’s hardware and software teams. Their predictions are not evidence that the feature can drive without supervision.
Asked how many lines of code the system contains, Musk says more code is not inherently better. He says neural networks also involve statistical models and matrix calculations, so line count is a poor measure of their capability.
Replacing many parts with large castings
Musk says consolidating parts reduces joins, sealing work and manufacturing complexity.
Munro compares reducing code with reducing parts. Musk says an organization can optimize individual pieces correctly yet produce an unnecessarily complicated assembly when those pieces are combined.
He says joining different materials requires several fastening methods and protection against corrosion. Gaps also need sealant, creating opportunities for leaks or noise if application is imperfect.
Musk argues that a large casting can replace many components, joins and sealing steps. He says the Model Y rear casting reduced the size of its body shop and eliminated hundreds of robots from that portion of production.
Munro says he had long advocated large structural castings. Musk says changing an existing high-volume production line is difficult because the factory must keep producing while changes are made.
A battery pack that helps stiffen the car
They explain how cells could contribute to a structural sandwich and discuss dimensional tolerances.
They discuss a design with front and rear castings joined by a structural battery pack. Musk says combining battery and chassis engineering is a coupled problem that was difficult to pursue while the company was developing its earlier vehicles.
He compares the pack to a sandwich structure: the cells help transfer forces between upper and lower layers instead of being carried only as cargo. He says the aim is to use the cells for both energy storage and stiffness.
Musk says bonding material can both hold the cells and provide fire-retardant properties. Munro describes this as multifunctional design and says his team built a model to explain the idea.
They explain that bonding many connecting elements between two sheets can make a flexible assembly much stiffer. Musk says greater torsional stiffness can change how a vehicle feels on the road.
Musk uses a skater drawing in their arms to explain why concentrating mass near the center changes rotational inertia. He says the same principle can affect how quickly a car rotates.
Munro says assembling many separate pieces makes dimensional accuracy difficult. Musk agrees that variation across components can accumulate and that fewer parts can reduce variation between vehicles.
Musk points to the fit of Lego bricks as an example of precision in an inexpensive manufactured item. Munro then praises the structural accuracy of the BMW i3’s carbon-fiber body.
Materials, wiring and the electric transition
The conversation covers thermal expansion, casting alloys and vehicle electrical systems.
Musk notes that different materials expand by different amounts as temperature changes. He says a mixed-material door and frame must account for that difference so they do not bind in hot or cold conditions.
He says Tesla developed an aluminum alloy for large castings that could achieve useful properties without a later heat-treatment step that might distort the part. Earlier castings, he says, were harder to scale because of warping.
The two discuss the value of materials science in engineering. Musk says that was the field he had planned to study in graduate school before leaving the program.
Munro discusses how the transition to electric vehicles changes the need for engine and transmission production. He recalls predicting that electric and hybrid vehicles would become a majority of sales around 2030; Musk offers a similar 2021 forecast.
They turn to wiring. Musk says there is room to improve vehicle wiring and calls the traditional 12-volt system a legacy constraint; they discuss higher-voltage low-voltage systems and thinner wires.
Musk says the new Model S and Model X were moving to a lithium-ion 12-volt auxiliary battery. He expects its service life to align better with the main battery pack.
The pair discuss carrying data and power more efficiently instead of using many separate point-to-point wires. Musk says a faster shared data network could reduce the amount of wiring.
Leadership and the transition to supervised driving
Musk discusses management and warns that a mostly capable system can invite complacency.
Munro asks about management education. Musk argues that leaders should understand how products and operations work, rather than relying on a business-school credential alone.
Both criticize short selling. Musk alleges that some traders took positions against Tesla and promoted negative information; he argues against short selling more generally.
Munro returns to the supervised driving beta. Musk says a system that works most of the time can create a dangerous transition if drivers become complacent before it can handle unusual cases.
They speculate about future vehicles taking an incapacitated occupant home or to a hospital and predict safety benefits. Tesla’s current [FSD (Supervised) instructions](https://www.tesla.com/support/fsd) require a fully attentive driver and say the feature does not make the vehicle autonomous.